as long as they're in china suddenly america cares about taiwan again suddenly america carries a cares are so much about hong kong and democracy there it doesn't care about these things in saudi arabia the values of the of the values are consistent values they could be consistently applied but they're only select that we have played against are going to be governments and so i believe it's a very aggressive very had germanic foreign policy military policy and let's face it. the there's been a reorientation of us military doctrine so that the war on terror is all yesterday now it's major power conflict so in order to take the american people to war against china or conflict with china or russia you have to convince them that they're very evil and what makes them evil they don't have our values ok matt in light in london i'll let you to reply ok go ahead yes no i think i thought that you did not say that you should use force to invade other countries i think that the invention in iraq was a mistake whether it was technically neco all because there were a number of un security council res

we who is of the international think we're safer as you say america is not a leader america is not trying to control everything 'd that is just part of a chuck of the knife not a question of holding trying to the rules of the american order. it's a question now what sort of a warder exists in the world the united states is not even this part shall now understand that the threat to the international order is recognised not simply by the united states but by europe well is demonstrated by the fact that the british are sending a carrier strike the south china sea the french are sending a submarine the german hurst the germans you sending us your friendship is a growing awareness of what china's aggressiveness and your inhibitions well who ambitions mean not just united states or for europe as well and i expect that will continue sort of to the end washington sort of that it is china a military threat and became a miner the british going all the way around the world to to the south china sea which from the stars i know has that be it where china is the south china sea is called that for a rea

when i see black america, i see part of my so when i was growing up like america spoke to me when white australia did not. those who say black lives matter is a movement we are importing from america. no, nothing of who we are. i lived in a world where wife lives mattered, and i was not wide like missing. and i wasn't known from black america. i learned how to speak back to whiteness. aboriginal people here more every die. we're out wanted system. now with the police were out with 2 states, i'm scared that more children are going to grow up in the country that think says no racism, but they're more likely to end up in the criminal justice system. then there are the fellow friends in daycare, rochester suspended, permanent mister tomato from next month. the moose is a direct response to the ministry lines recently, kicking out 8 russian diplomats ready for action, russia. there was one section of the north trinity pipeline with natural gas. and always the green line from regulate to the stop to blind europe, that the commissioner warns energy po was withdrawn, the continent is on the ris

of america and i believe it's also joe biden's way of telling it to ron that america will not be written in to the. a c.p.i. . you know it's an insurgent interesting norge number one in the western publics are never explain what iran is doing in syria as marcus rightly points out they're invited there and they're fighting jihad it's violent terrorist groups ok and that is never explained to the it's the western publics and number 2 i guess you know joe's right america is back back bombing and it in and i would use slightly different terminology the mark as you know maintaining american hegemony they're making they're saying no we will challenge and even though they have no answers for the quagmire that they've created for themselves in the region go ahead george that's exactly right that quagmire was in large part created by the obama and biden the administration when they cynically and ruthlessly tried to exploit the arab spring in 2011 to bring about a series of regime changes in the arab world. it started it was in libya and then it moved into syria and it's becoming increasingly clea

great again not for tropical siddur america is economic decline to reduce its relevance in the world so he wanted more return on investment if you want for their military deployments and. they're very practical in those terms are transactional while biden sees the liberal decline of the u.s. to be the source of us wrote reduced relevance in the world and also very explicit about this is all in the speech because i want to link it was a cultural revolution going through in the us at the moment i want to refer to scourge of white supremacy and u.s.c. was very explicit this link to foreign policy as well because. our values at home will be you know how we lead in the world while trying to lead with economic dominance and sees it as leading on value so also this was. a lot of the speech to focus on the product allies the values. that it's logical conclusion then joe biden is talking about a colored revolution in america ok so we can talk about that a little bit later i mean these things that end up being connected in i think connected in people where people don't understand the law of un

they do not want the enmity of america. america still has leverage. we're holding that $10000000000.00 for their, their, their, their foreign exchange account with a lot of aid is america can turn offer on much of the foreign aid and the attitude of europe towards afghanistan. so we hold some cards, but we have to do that realistically. we're not going to overturn this government. we're not going to shape the government in the future. this is going to be a taliban government. it's been very clear. but we do have some ships to trade with and our big interest is that the policy on not caudal al qaeda as it did in its 1st round. and we know that the, the present head of state mala hunt was a foreign minister in the previous government leading up to 2001. and, and he defended al qaeda and, and we have to make sure that he does not defend archive this time. and all of our efforts should be really focused on making sure that he understands that and he does not do it. and then we will have, you know, if we can accomplish that single fact we will have accompl

. indeed, i believe that both america and britain have retains that influence america by having come to an informal agreement with the taliban. because the taliban were never defeated militarily by america and britain. and secondly, it was just inconceivable that the telephone telephone on their own could have conquered africanist on countries so large. so the 5 different regions simply on their own note, the american military gave the go ahead and also as well. american doesn't have to have soldiers in the country as a control country. it can control a country for control in this country's economy. turn into the shanghai cooperation organization. if this is what it is, 1st go ahead. shanghai cooperation organization is a ration alliance, including countries such as russia, china, central asia, and now iran. and it focuses on issues semi for security to economics. so politics and it's a very good alliance because it means back to all of the countries involved on. now, members of the shanghai cooperation organization and iran having been as mrs . so the alliance demonstrates how iran'

there's 2 americas but one america whether it's the left or the democrat party thinks they know a lot about the people and they have a position set of positions there's another america that's leans republican that's conservative it's much more populous now it's much more working class now it's actually much darker than it was meaning color of the skin than it was before it's actually got look this president who is hitler had prominent gay americans say he stood up for us he was on our side you don't hear that oh my point is only this the movement in america peter that is being missed by posters is people that don't want to say about what they believe because tech and the media are saying your bad if you believe that the fine people hoax is supposed to make me not talk about president trump's record on freeing people who are in prison for too long and being kind to and being aggressive to protect gay rights overseas in other places so it's a it is a we're in a moment where that 2nd piece of america you're describing i think it's a bigger than a majority and i think it's angrier now abo

remember jim crow came from the democratic party but you know you have been i said let's talk about america we don't need a point senator my exwife more hispanics and other minorities know carmen point when they expanded the ted ok for the party for the time being when he got his got i think one thing one of the huge legacy maybe in my mind maybe defining legacy you know it's not really a policy per se is that we realize that the country doesn't know much about the other and if they do they don't like what they see. whether there's no doubt that our country is fundamentally broken i mean look i i was only took an oath to uphold and defend the constitution of the united states of america against all enemies foreign and domestic and i agree with laura you take on the constitution you're need to go and i think what donald trump did on the on the on the 6. january was a frontal assault against the constitution united states trying to stop a process mandated by the 12th amendment from occurring whether you agree with what they were doing or not doesn't matter the constitution mandated you can't.

that i think you commissioner, wounds and shoot over to his were on the continent, is on the rise. america told envoy top got his tongue resigned that comes as the inspection general plans to launch multiple investigations into a marcus chaos military pull out at the station over to plumb matic operations. i tortured and jailed for 17 years without trial. august 20 national still languishes in guantanamo bay despite being cleared for release. after it's a mash had been mistaken for terrorists. they had lines joined. my colleagues were so shy the top of the hour with more news for you. ok, next on i'll say international as the cross dog and for all you can use and the renegade incorporated with with hello and welcome to cross talk. we're all things considered. i'm peter lavelle. there are growing indications that washington isn't finished with afghanistan just yet. military involvement has come to an end, not engagement. also, we were told there is an energy crisis. maybe this is part of the grant reset. ah, to discuss these issues and more. busy i'm joined by my guess, marcus papadopoulos

he grew those populations in america because he put america 1st is not because he's donald trump and he's some cult figure. it's because he put america 1st and because he said, damn the torpedoes of the swamp monsters and told them all where they could go. and americans love that they've been craving that for so long. they wanted to get rid of all this chinese and the mit romney's, you know, at least quiet them or put them over and the other party where they belong or on a mess. and b, c is jen, jen said, but they never belong at the head of our party and somehow they kept getting power through the apparatus. so those days are over now that the people can see what they can do when they demand their own candidate. and as long as donald trump has thousands those values, he is the man to watch in both 20222024. and as long as we re establish selection integrity, he will win and he will win in record record numbers. well, you know, again, let me go to david in new york, and again, let's look at the mechanics here. we know the power of big tech, and the in kind influence it had on the ele

ology in america for 2030 years in his spoken manufacturing consent. i mean a lot of things are likely you know the entrepreneurship of the chinese society where the business aspect the meritocracy here in china if you talk about how the chinese leader us i mean they're selected we went through a grueling college placement process pretty much like those in russia we study school art math physics sighing saying either to get ahead in society and mean you know i'm i'm i'm just you know i understand within a couple of years they'll be more stem students students spending stem in china then the entire western world the reason i say already there's an it's about priorities and what kind of society you want to have good go. yeah i mean you didn't hear these things in a western society. if there were to be a successful country unquote we control is you know south korea is often cited i mean stream media or receded or china was you know often mentioned by the negative lights in that they started this and they some ways for them for exploited this virus to dama

and america and britain, which of course, all the heart and soul of nato, are intent on bring in the ukraine into its ranks. because a ukraine in the ranks of nights. so the main that russia is and so on it's western border, it would mean that russian supremacy in the black sea region would be seriously compromised. because even as we talk now, the americans are referred to shit. the at odessa, an article in ukraine to accommodate american and british will shit. so what we see at the moment in the black sea region and in ukraine is a measure that the americans and the british are going to take. they now have ukraine in their orbits. they are going to do if the thing they possibly can, with the exception of defending ukraine, militarily, they will do everything they can to ensure that ukraine remains in their presence. so one of the options to russia, well gosh, is, does have options in ukraine. and quite frankly, ukraine should never have been allowed to enter the west or beach in the 1st place . the dangers emanates at the end of 2013 in ukraine. and for russia were very obvious, bu

i most of you, that's the well, it is beginning to reach a climax regarding ukraine because america's goes in of russia has served a purpose. specifically, buying washington have been proven to play increased naval. ready presence in the black sea, this has inevitably about a response from russia, and that has provided the americans with a pretext to increase, not only nato's a presence in the boat and in eastern europe. but it is also enabled the americans to increase their military and economic assistance to ukraine. so the americans and the british on now supplying ukraine with sophisticated weaponry. at the same time, the international monetary fund, which of course is a weapon of washington and london, has agreed to release funds for ukraine. so we can see that a very dangerous picture is american. and the americans and the british are now in a position to cement that vision in your crime, as you're saying is, is that they're trying to provoke a response. this is the intention. yes, they are trying to promote a response. but i think primarily they all look into and haunts their p

is a strategic partner for america the e.u. coordinates its fall policy and defense policy making with the americans alexina valley is a tool that the americans are using against the russians and i believe the americans i hope discuss no strings or the germans have kept so they counsel i will not allow that to happen so that is a good indication that the e.u. will try. draw each of the 5 the americans own similarly the americans all the dominant force in the e.u. that's the problem you know george clooney the argument coming out of washington that we have been now leading into the bike lane was breaking news that there are russia will have them ally in the dominate influence over europe's energy policy but i mean if you step back and say well no you won't be the europeans you want the europeans to buy your american liquefied natural gas so you will be reliant upon american companies and american born policy i mean if you step back here it's pretty obvious that the opera see a big mirror i mean gas is a company it has shareholde

politics but you won't get anyone that interferes in america. like a british citizen in 2016. yes no there's no question that that will be. part of the american general take a leader hungary with the blink who has a family connection with hungary with his father was a former ambassador. run out of time you know i want to thank my guests in oslo and in budapest i want to thank our viewers for watching us your r.v. see you next time remember. the day or thinks. we are here to ask. so we were. going to. give you more. now. on those who just came up with a ticket in your show that. antarctica is a very international community. media used to really need to. do this because this. is. but the. script. is everything. to do with. the. time they have to go out he decided not to take this life. with him i gave you the. vaccine program with the goal of immunizing more than half the country's population by the end of the year. in argentina for the russian jobs soaring up and. so ahead of them this hour following a wave of allergic reactions california all nations from aids. drugs which com

we have look we've a he is an independent journalist and in cork we cross to geoffrey robertson as america's professor of history at university college cork and a member of the royal irish academy original macross up rules in effect that means you can jump in anytime you want and i always appreciate it ok let's go to john in paris if you heard my introduction here until the e.u. or respects russian treats russia as an equal partner this relationship isn't going to move anywhere it is a it is basically in a deep freeze right now and i and i and personally i think it's the e.u. that has to take the 1st step but i don't think they're up to it go ahead john i totally agree i don't think there's any prospect now of the relationship improving there are very few voices in the european union who are in favor of it improving you can count them on the fingers of one hand. and instead to the vast majority of european politicians want to break off or break down relations with russia as much as they can for a whole host of reasons of which i think the most important is that they actually thrive on this n

so i decided to travel to one of the most toxic places in america, florida. one of florida's biggest industries and best kept secrets, is phosphoric wine in the biggest player. it was $85000000000.00 industry. is mosaic, and i, there are reports of millions of gallons of contaminated water now flowing into the florida aquifer may pro, there's a chronic i don't live here that work towards me, but that's what it is. i'm in 2013, my uncle, our family dog, my brother, who is 21 years old, myself and my father. we're all guy raw prov, kidney problems with the whole and the good way. yeah. maybe they'll actually work is more important than next saturday, financial survival guide. daisy, let's learn about feel out. let's say i'm a show i can hear me from grief on face of the fight. wall street prod, thank you for helping with enjoy. that right. fell out equal des slavery ah ah hello and welcome to cross stock were all things are considered. i'm peter lavelle . what is the national mood? i suppose it depends on what kind of media you consume to say the nation is divi

a significant difference one of the things that biden has made clear is that he plans to work with america's allies more and also follow more multilateral approaches to china which is different from what what trump did trump was much more into unilateral bullying and it didn't work frankly didn't work it didn't get him results and china itself counterproposals with essential it here it's too little tell at all rules that is the w t o and other kinds of global rules so actually in some sense china's speaking a better liberal game than the united states is in this case because trump has been kind of a nationalist only and previous american presidents have typically been good at saying that well we should have one set of rules that applies to all countries and that of your cio of course is the place where most trade rules are enforced. ok and so it's going to be a shame when what do you what do you think about that and in looking at the new bike administration because if tony blinken is to be believed and we know that is the assumption that trent trump was a bit on bass thick with china how doe

so the gulf of mexico, you would see america take very, very clinical. ready response, it is no different for russia in the black sea, but it's very interesting, patrick it. ukraine is also necessary for nato because ukraine gives nato a reason to exist. ok, because they, they claim nato's opposition is that it's a defensive alliance. and then projects stability. however, army ever more sophisticated weapons to kim is the stabilizing. it's the stabilizing to the, the conflict that is going on inside of ukraine. we need to remind our viewers. this is an intra ukraine conflict that i believe the west russia to be involved in is always said this is an internal conflict dom bass of course. but if the dumbasses attacked, which would basically be a form of ethnic cleansing, of don bass rushes. and this is a red line here, so again, adding all the elements for a possible military action in it as we just heard mark to say, if this could happen by accident. but i have a feeling lot of people in washington in london would love to see an accident. go ahead. yeah, a

we need that back in america. that's how we have that true, progressive spirit that honors human beings and does not discourage hard work, doesn't discourage showing up on time, doesn't discourage individual personhood and tried to lump this all into little members of tribes that have to go to war with each other that doesn't solve anything, the true spirit that made america were the most prosperous nations in the whole world. we've got to revive that, like it better than ever before. we can rely upon these monopolies and that's for sure. okay, they destroy innovation. okay. these monopolies of the line. let me go back. you, you brought up january 6. i want to end on it here. we keep hearing about it. it's drip, drip, drip, drip. though no one has been charged with sedition and treason so far. i mean, where is this going because what i watch here is that this is a perfect distraction about really what's happening. i mean, we're seeing huge changes, social changes, economic changes happening to honda, tens of milli

measure is a movement we are importing from america. no, nothing of who we are. i lived in a world where white lives mattered. and i was not white like amazon, and i wasn't known from black america. i learned how to speak back to whiteness. aboriginal people here, i'm more every die. you're out, wanted them now with the police were out with statistics. i'm scared that more children are going to grow up in the country that think says no racism, but they're more likely to end up in the criminal justice system. then there are other fellow friends in daycare. ah ah, welcome back to cross talk. we're all things are considered. i'm peter le belt, remind you we're discussing russia's relations with the west. ah. okay, let's go back to charles, get shot. you were at starting. you started a point before we went to the break and i want to add a developer. a little bit more, charles, i mean, you know, when we're looking at these blocks, you know, the e, you were looking at nato, but i mean, you already alluded to it. i mean, a, china is very impor

you know, that which is what america, average americans who are making decisions. and i think it's, it's really important to put in perspective the conservatives are trying to keep the power in the hands of the individuals to not put them into the institution, such as the courts. and then you talk about my favorite subject, one of the problems we do have in what in the elite is that the media is controlled with the exception of fox and a few other publications is controlled by, you know, very liberal leads to do 2 things. one is they dominate, you know, outlets like cnn, cnn, and m, s, b c. and then they now dominate, you know, the social media, facebook and twitter. and there's absolutely repression in the united states of people who's, who's, who's message and beliefs are not the same as those who control the elite media. and that, you know, was unfortunate because the reality is that people communicate these days not by standing on street corners and yelling, but by posting messages on facebook and twitter and so forth. and that's something it really needs to be

america's manufacturing industry back to the united states biden has identified anything of that nature when well let me talk about america's national interest each talking about values rather use had nothing to do with national interest i mean they just. becomes of the justification for pointless interventionist wars you know or it or it's a budget line for diversity but again that still addressing the do domestic audience here you know mark one of one of the things that i find very interesting is that i look at the obama administration's foreign policy with the exception of iran which will talk in the 2nd part of the program is basically a failure or a failing grade ok but even seems to me that they just want to put it back in super charge again i mean there doesn't seem to be any kind of critical analysis some of the mistakes made during the obama administration and weaknesses and coming to terms with the consequences about foreign policy joe biden just like george st bernard talk about about the use them policy go ahead but yeah i think it's worth mentioning afghanistan as well as i

live from the world headquarters of r t america our nation's capital. with rick sanchez. hi everybody i'm rick sanchez and i want to welcome our viewers from all over the world including those who are watching us right now on the portable t.v. out there is a story that we are following right now that sounds like something. that happens often here in the united states let me show you what we're talking about it's a gunman that has burst into a school and he has started shooting he's injured at least 16 people killed 7 children it sounds like something that would happen in a place like kansas right or arizona but this shooting you're looking at right there that's russia. it's happened in a russian city called. were authorities with the national anti-terrorism agency say the shooter has now been apprehended the area is in lockdown motive is still unknown expect to get a lot more information on the story we're going to be following for you throughout this newscast throughout the day but there's another tragedy that's taking place in another part of the world and this one is.

and i wasn't new from black america. i learned how to speak back to one regional people here every day will be the place where out more when she speaks, i'm scared that more children are going to grow up in the country that think says no racism, but they're more likely to end up in the criminal justice system, then they're all the fellow friends in daycare, a raw when i was just a safe out the scene because of the advocate and engagement. it was the trail. when so many find themselves worlds apart, we choose to look so common ground. oh is your media a reflection of reality? in a world transformed what will make you feel safe? isolation, whole community? are you going the right way or are you being led somewhere? direct. what is true? what is great? in the world corrupted, you need to descend a join us in the depths or remain in the shallows. ah, our top story, this, our russia and months is it's to suspend a work bill bits permanent, mission, 10, nato in brussels from november. first, the measure is a response to nato's

that are on our show at the fair are rather across the top the for 4th america is a. political battle but i'm in the new. kid and. i didn't lose a child for 12 all that it. was then i'm all in my michelle little. number set up around the hey how not do it. and get this whole food place choice i knew you didn't pay i think time in syria says. pretty she ought to have a. model for the name after the couple fucked around with mr hates it for jim and then oil for folks that are fairly in your court. is your media a reflection of reality. in a world transformed. what will make you feel safe. isolation full community. are you going the right way or are you being led so. diluted. what is truth what's his face. in the world corrupted you need to descend. to join us in the depths. or a maybe in the shallows. italy's prime minister says rome will have to make its own decision about whether to purchase russia's sputnik v. shot if the youth e.u. regulator doesn't give the covert vaccine its approval. to british controlled territories rejects a government plan to send migrants the

and i wasn't known from black america. i learned how to speak back to whitefish aboriginal people here. i'm more every day. we are now with the police were out with 2 states. i'm scared that more children are going to grow up in the country that think says no racism, but they're more likely to end up in the criminal justice system. then there are other killer friends in daycare and i drink, shaped by for some of those with for dare's sinks. we dare to ask ah, russia welcome back. the 1st ever spaced film crew off to that 12 day shoes on the international space station. well, extreme pressure flaming turbulence, the new pioneers of orbital cinema, describe that fiery decided from space. we speak also to that of the lead actress a 15. any of them with european leaders confirm that russia is not withholding natural gas applies to europe. but media outlets keep up the narrative that moscow deliberately pushing up the price for.

problems with corporate consolidation of power are absolutely are there deep challenges that america faces yet we've never had a leader that fundamentally sought to exploit and was willing to burn down the democracy in the process and so i can hear it since well theory about how the riots started and who was responsible for that insurrection but one of the interesting things. one of the one of the interesting things is that people and the american people are are near unanimous in their disapproval of what happened last week and within the republican party there are deep divisions as to how to move forward because they see that this pursuit of burn down the house is not something that's going to be tenable for that which could potentially moving forward i see a relevance and his ability to continue will really sort of fade as he exits the stage and the reason he won't go away but the reason it will stage is because the incentive of the american people to basically preserve our democracy on some level is going to went out and i don't see how you can look at the the vast majority of the

then was for i think we're part of america 1st from. wells about to cross top where all things are considered i'm peter lavelle this is the home edition and we're discussing we'll. ok let's go back to marcus here let's change gears gentlemen we had a week ago the disastrous summit meeting of china in the united states in the american city of anchorage i think it's widely agreed maybe from very many different perspectives it was a real train wreck but it had to be expected here and now we have. american and british warships in exercises are around taiwan in agreement between the united states and taiwan about coastguard exercises is heating up here but you know marcus one of the things that i find very troubling is that the lack of knowledge of the inability to actually look at the origins of u.s. chinese relations since the the revolution was under the carter administration where diplomatic relations were established and when that was happening it was accepted and it was accepted when nixon went to china taiwan is part of china ok and a

well, i should say, 1st of all, peter, my opinion on america and i kind of stone runs country. so many analysts and journalists are saying, because i do not believe america slash scottish stone. indeed, i believe that both america, britain have retains that influence and i'm going to stop by having come to an informal agreement with the taliban because the telephone were never defeated militarily by america and britain. and secondly, it was just inconceivable that the telephone telephone on their own could have conquered afghanistan. i country so large, so the fine so diverse, different regions simply on their own notes. the american military gave the go ahead and also as well. america doesn't have to have soldiers in the country in order to control that country. it can control a country for control in this country's economy. turn into the shanghai cooperation organization. this is what it is. first go ahead is shanghai corporation organization is a your asian alliance including countries such as russia, china, central asia, and now iran. and it focuses on issues, i mean, for s

i have to be onto the teeth that that's all america . we can't trust the police, we can't trust the government. we can't trust anyone except or so to protect ourselves in driven by dreamers shaped by those in me dares think we dare to ask me. o is your media a reflection of reality in a world transformed what will make you feel safer? type relation. community you going the right way? where are you being somewhere? which direction? what is truth? is faith, the in the world corrupted. you need to this end. the join us in the depths will remain in the shallows, ah ah, watching off into national in the headlines on this monday, the kremlin luxury offered allocations over atrocities carried out by russian army instructors and the central african republic. it's all in a new un security council report or pertained by the new york times a potential death blow to the u. s. case against julian sanchez. as washington's main witness admits, in an interview with slender media that he gave full testimony. who needs russian hackers when they're a briti

and now china's caught up to america and now all that money of printing that's been going on for 2025 years is going to show up as real inflation. and then as that happens the usual. but if you have australian version there you go this route you have the people. who are. going to be used to the machine up to the nearest. you know. the best of the. study to go to look to interest you just that she. needs to but it seems to me. so did you begin to go to church with this new look at a lot of these older title to put it you'll do good because there will be a choice to be on your voters will show you switch to a little research on the cost or would have thought of this too free with should do coke with full attention you. want a few that beautiful hear them mostly where you never have. to put so that you put in the. qur'an dish. for more gas to jenny hutt just. gould. b.s.t. when you need the most would you have the biggest loss within the city to you are just stuck i don't know that you just what does libby speech you could you know when you were going in there still usually does. the. tr

if there are multiple legacies depending on how you view trump there also can be no doubt he changed america and the presidency. to discuss legacies i'm joined by my guest scott ritter and omar he is a former intelligence officer in the united nations weapons inspector in new orleans we have brian trasher he is a trunk for president 2020 sarah get and in san diego we have laura frank she is founder and c.e.o. of group l. communications and a democratic strategist all right across topples in effect that means you can jump in anytime you want and i always appreciate it ok let's go to scott 1st your son you wrote an article for r t a couple days ago. basically discussing trump's legacy and you wrote this biden will be sworn in as the $46.00 president the united states and in 4 years of an experiment in populist politics headed by trump it was for better or worse unique in american history can you elaborate a little bit on that well certainly i mean the moment donald trump came down the escalator in trump tower and announced his candidacy was a can a sea unlike anything we've seen in modern hist