Three years ago in a debate, you were clear on this, you said an earned pathway was amnesty. Yet you've changed your mind here. Why? Do you support a path to citizenship for immigrants who are in the United States, but are here illegally? I do, but first we have to do two things. Did he resist the the pathway to citizenship for the 11 million? No, he understood it. He molded it. He made it. Why isn't that amnesty? Because in fact you are giving legal status to people who have broken the law. Keep the Promise I is responsible for the content of this advertising.