Skip to main content

tv   The Last Word With Lawrence O Donnell  MSNBC  October 21, 2021 7:00pm-8:00pm PDT

7:00 pm
it's friday eve, which means tomorrow's friday. that's going to do it for us tonight,ly see you again tomorrow when it will be actually friday. now it's time for "the last word" with lawrence o'donnell. good evening, lawrence. >> good evening, rachel. you know how we were discussing the other night, senate, creatures of the senate, as you put it, are slow in evolving on changes in senate rules, like the 60 vote threshold, the so-called filibuster rule. there was some public evolving tonight, which i actually think has been going on right before our eyes without him saying it
7:01 pm
quite so clearly from president biden. he said tonight that he absolutely is open to changing that rule for voting rights legislation, and he said for other things, possibly for other things, and he also made it very, very clear tonight that the reason he hasn't been able to do any of that stuff or talk about any of that stuff in a detailed way is that would create more problems with joe manchin, more problems with senator sinema, more problems with some other possible problems with other moderate democrats, and so he doesn't want to get into that rules fight until he gets his legislative package done. but he isn't -- it's pretty clear he's not going to stay out of it once he gets his legislative package done. >> the question is chicken and egg, right? you can't get the legislative package done if you talk about those things, but if you don't deal with those things, you can't get the legislative package done, right? so i mean, we'll see. but if -- to the extent that the
7:02 pm
legislative package includes voting rights, right, to the extent that his priorities include -- anyway, the president's evolution on this is important. >> yeah, no, the legislative package i'm referring to of course is just the reconciliation bill, which bypasses that whole 60 vote threshold thing. he's got to get that done, and then, yes, you don't get anything done after that. not a single thing. nothing moves through the senate after that if you leave that 60 vote threshold in place. >> but we'll see with senator manchin and senator sinema having the kind of leverage they do right now, we'll see what's in that legislative package ultimately when it gets to the end of the sausage making process. i mean, it feels to me like, you know, there's a lot of excitement yesterday that something was going to get done by the end of this week, and then manchin strolled into the middle of it all, pulled the silverware drawer out, i'm still not ready to have the spotlight off of me. i want this to keep going on and
7:03 pm
on and and on. i don't, if the president is wait for that to happen before everything else moves on, i don't know when that's going to happen. >> there's some noises tonight indicating that there could actually be a deal tomorrow and possibly something of a breakthrough with senator sinema. but i will know if there's a deal tomorrow tomorrow. that's when i'll know if there's a deal tomorrow. >> that's exactly right. >> and that holds every day are from this point forward. >> and when it happens, we will all turn to you to explain to us whether or not it's real, whether or not it works, and whether or not it's going to make a difference in our lives. >> it will be very clear to everyone. it won't need any explanation from me. it will be one of those clear deals. >> thank you, rachel. >> thank you, lawrence. it actually does appear that there could be a major breakthrough tonight in the democrats' negotiations to reach an agreement in that biden legislative agenda. "politico" is reporting tonight that senator kyrsten sinema has
7:04 pm
agreed to a revenue package that actually would include some tax increases on wealthy taxpayers and would be enough to pay for close to $2 trillion of the new -- of new spending for climate policies, education, child care, and family leave. a source familiar with the discussions told "politico," devote, senator sinema has agreed to provisions in each of president biden's four proposed revenue categories, internationals, domestic corporate, high net worth individuals, and tax enforcement providing sufficient revenue to fully pay for a budget reconciliation package in the range currently being discussed. and of course the range currently being discussed is 1.75 trillion to 2 trillion.
7:05 pm
the range defined by joe manchin as his limit. now, this statement does seem to represent a shift in senator sinema's position, which had been reported as being opposed to any tax increases in the biden bill. and earlier tonight, president biden described senator sinema's position this way. >> she's smart as the devil, number one. number two, she's very supportive of the environmental agenda in my legislation, very supportive. she's supportive of almost all the things i mentioned relating to everything from family care to all those issues. where she's not supportive is she says she will not raise a single penny in taxes on the corporate side and/or on wealthy people, period, and so that's where it sort of breaks down. >> senator sinema's public silence about what she is trying to achieve in the legislation
7:06 pm
has led to what the "new york times" today called a, quote, crescendo of anger and pressure that ms. sinema is facing from erstwhile allies who say they are perplexed by her recent tactics. we'll be joined by one of those who added tremendously to the pressure on senator sinema today by being part of a group of veterans who released this ad. >> dear senator sinema, as members of your veterans advisory council, we feel as though we are being used as a window dressing for your own image and not to provide council on what's best for arizonians. you repeatedly ignored our feedback urging you to act on three issues that support our veterans and the heart of our nation. we must protect voting rights. we are appalled by your failure to address this issue. you campaigned on lowering
7:07 pm
prescription drug price, but now you're opposing the build back better act. are you choosing to answer to big donors rather than arizonans. these are not the actions of a maverick. as such, we respectfully resign from your veterans advisory council. sincerely, sylvia gonzalez anders. >> dana allman. >> call on senator sinema to support the build back better act now. >> senator sinema and senator joe manchin have been the only holdouts in the democratic senate on the bill. they would both have to be part of any agreement on a framework for the bill. tonight joe biden gave the simplest description of the challenge of working with only 50 democrats in the senate. >> look, when you're in the united states senate and you're president of the united states, and you have 50 democrats, every one is a president.
7:08 pm
every single one. >> today house speaker nancy pelosi seemed to say that the democrats might be able to reach an agreement on the basic outlines of the biden social infrastructure bill tomorrow. today senator jon tester said there could be an agreement tomorrow. >> if school is still it appears has a framework by tomorrow, is that realistic in your eyes? >> absolutely. >> what are the remaining sticking points? >> my perspective? >> yeah. >> just top line. >> the actual number? >> joe manchin seemed to confirm a report featured on this program that he was thinking about leaving the democratic party. david corn reported to mother jones in recent day senator joe manchin has told associates that he is considering leaving the democratic party if president joe biden and democrats on capitol hill do not agree to his demand to cut the size of the
7:09 pm
social infrastructure bill from 3.5 trillion to 1.75 trillion, according to people who have heard manchin discuss this, manchin has said that if this were to happen, he would declare himself an men independent. manchin told associates that he was prepared to initiate his exit plan earlier this week and had mentioned the possibility to biden. joe manchin had a colorful response to david corn's reporting beginning with a capital b. >> i can't control rumors and it's bull [ bleep ] bull [ bleep ] spelled with a b-u-l-l capital b. >> and then today joe manchin said this. >> senator, have you ever had had a plan to switch parties? have you ever -- >> no, i'll be very honest with you, anything that was ever said, if i'm an embarrassment to my -- my democrat colleague s my caucus, the president of the
7:10 pm
party, chuck schumer and all them, and i said me being a moderate centrist democrat, if that causes you a problem let me know and i'll switch to being an independent. i'd still be caucusing with democrats. >> leading us off tonight is claire mccaskill, an msnbc political analyst. we need the senate expertise tonight for this. i want to begin with senator sinema because president biden in his town hall discussion tonight seemed to indicate that there was no movement or no movement that he was aware of or prepared to talk about on tax revenues from senator sinema. now we have this "politico" reporting, which indicates there is some possibility of senator sinema being willing to agree to an amount of revenue through various devices that might not involve individual tax rates. might involve other things. but that seems, if true, to be a
7:11 pm
way to get there and to get there soon. >> yeah, i think kyrsten sinema has really hurt herself by not talking about what she's for. i understand that she believes very strongly that negotiations should occur in private and that she will fully explain her vote when she makes her vote, and it will become apparent what she worked for and what she cares about. but in the interim, the vacuum is being filled by a lot of anger towards her. i've been on the phone all day, lawrence, as you might imagine with a bunch of different senators in my party. i am confident that the "politico" reporting is correct, that she has, in fact, agreed to a number of revenue enhancers in various ways that will make this
7:12 pm
bill be paid for. i think, frankly, now, the problem is some of the details as it relates to joe manchin, particularly around climate. kyrsten sinema is big on the climate part. she really thinks that's the most important part of this bill. joe manchin is still struggling with some of the details, and when you only got 50 as the president said, everybody has power, and i know it's frustrating for everyone, but that's why elections really matter and why margins of majorities matter. and i want to remind everyone that you don't build greater majorities from bright blue places. you build bigger majorities from places like wisconsin and ohio and pennsylvania and north carolina, and georgia and arizona, and nevada where both democrats and republicans can get elected. that used to be the case in my state, my state is now firmly red, but in all those states, that's how we get more democrats elected, and that's how we remove this incredible power
7:13 pm
that both manchin and sinema have at this very moment. >> yeah, and as we go forward, do you think from your sources today we heard what jon tester had to say, do you think it is possible that there could be some kind of announcement of a general agreement tomorrow? >> i doubt it. i think it slips to next week. i think terry mcauliffe is probably doing more than he's ever done to help the democrats in washington by having this election looming and people being nervous about a state that had drifted to the firmly blue side, now appearing to be up for grabs, and so i think everyone's feeling like we've got to get -- they've got to get some points on the board before that election so i would anticipate something happening next week. but it is thursday, and people took off on planes and trains today. they'll be talking over the weekend, but i have a feeling there may be some kind of loose
7:14 pm
framework that pelosi may talk about tomorrow. but in terms of an actual bill text and really knowing what's in it, i don't think that will happen before next week. >> oh, yeah, that's impossible. that's days away at least, but what they seem to be suggesting is tomorrow could be a day where there's an announcement that says we have all 50 democrats in the senate and we have the house agreed upon this framework with this number, for example, you know, 1.75, 2, whatever that number is with revenue from these areas. this is where the tax revenue would come from, not necessarily highly specific. but we would know where the tax revenue wasn't coming from, for example. they could tell us here's what's not going to be -- a lot of what the president did tonight, tonight the president said i don't think we're going to get this. i don't think we're going to get that. he talked about what we're not going to get. how many weeks of paid leave you might get, could be shorter. he went into a bunch of
7:15 pm
specifics tonight that could be the kind of thing that are announced in a general framework. i mean, we know -- i mean, the staff of the senate finance committee and the house ways and means committee, they haven't even heard what kyrsten sinema's tax proposals are, and they are the people who have to write these things, and they can't write those overnight. >> yeah, except the problem in this instance is that joe manchin has been saying to folks i want to see the details before i sign off on it. so there is -- you know, rachel referred to it chicken and egg, there is one of the problems of announcing a framework because i'm not sure manchin will sign the dotted line on a framework without the details. >> all right. so we will -- we will see what happens tomorrow. claire mccaskill says you can skip tomorrow's news on this -- on this particular story. >> yeah. and by the way, lawrence, i also said the dodgers were going to win the series on "morning joe" the other morning.
7:16 pm
so you know, tune in tomorrow to once again find claire was wrong. >> you do have a little more authority when it comes to the united states senate. claire mccaskill, thank you very much for starting us off tonight. really appreciate it. >> you bet. >> thank you. and joining us now is sylvia gonzalez anders, one of the members of senator sinema's veterans advisory council who resigned from that position in protest. she served in the air force from 1974 to 1978. thank you very much for joining us tonight. you know, i am mystified by senator cinema. i have never seen senate behavior like this, certainly on the democratic side. i have no idea what she thinks about anything. you know her, you would have supported her. do you understand why the senator is going off in directions that are different from what you thought she would do when she was a candidate? >> well, thank you very much for having me.
7:17 pm
no, i don't understand where she's coming from or what her plan is. >> and what brought you to the point where you, in effect have, it sounds like given up on her. have you given up on her? >> no, i'm hoping with all this events that we can come back together because i really want to support her for re-election, but she has to keep her promises that she made to us for me to feel comfortable doing that. >> what was her reaction to you sending this letter to her basically resigning from this advisory group of hers? >> i got a very cordial voice mail from her. she was very polite, and she thanked me for my service, and that was about it. that was one of the few -- only the second personal interaction i've had with her. >> and what's -- what happened to your access to her after she won, after she became a senator
7:18 pm
compared to when she needed you for the campaign? >> it was very perfunctory and performative, it was always -- we felt like we were being used as props. >> and how important were veteran issues in her senate campaign? >> well, there were very serious issues that veterans had about prescription drug prices and veterans affairs, and so we really worked hard to get her elected, and we had the best of intentions in hoping that she would be the senator to really help us move forward. >> if you had picked up the phone when she called, what would you have said to her today? >> i would have said thank you very much. i appreciate your call. i really want you to really consider why we have done this and to try to take an attention to it and really help us move
7:19 pm
forward. this is what we want more than anything. we want to protect democracy. this whole thing is not about politics. it is only about the fear that we have about democracy being under attack. >> sylvia gonzalez andersh. thank you very much for joining our discussion tonight. >> thank you very much, i appreciate it. >> thank you. coming up, tonight the u.s. attorney in washington, d.c., received the contempt referral that was approved by a bipartisan vote in the house of representatives today against stove bannon. congressman madeline dean will join us next. join us next cosentyx can help you look and feel better by treating the multiple symptoms of psoriatic arthritis. don't use if you're allergic to cosentyx. before starting, get checked for tuberculosis. an increased risk of infections—some serious— and the lowered ability to fight them may occur. tell your doctor about an infection or symptoms, or if you've had a vaccine or plan to.
7:20 pm
tell your doctor if your crohn's disease symptoms develop or worsen. serious allergic reactions may occur. watch me! get real relief with cosentyx. at vanguard, you're more than just an investor, you're an owner with access to financial advice, tools and a personalized plan that helps you build a future for those you love. vanguard. become an owner. ♪♪ your new pharmacy is here. to help you compare prices, and save on your medication.
7:21 pm
amazon prime members get select meds as low as $1 a month. who knew it could be this easy? your new pharmacy is amazon pharmacy. the new sensodyne repair and protect with deep repair has the science to show who knew it could be this easy? that the toothpaste goes deep inside the exposed dentin to help repair sensitive teeth. my patients are able to have that quality of life back. i recommend sensodyne repair and protect with deep repair. ♪ darling, i, i can't get enough of your love babe♪ ♪girl, i don't know, i don't know,♪ ♪i don't know why i can't get♪ applebee's. now that's eatin' good in the neighborhood. moving is a handful. applebee's. no kidding! fortunately, xfinity makes moving easy. easy? -easy? switch your xfinity services to your new address online in about a minute. that was easy. i know, right? and even save with special offers just for movers. really? yep! so while you handle that, you can keep your internet and all those shows you love,
7:22 pm
and save money while you're at it with special offers just for movers at xfinity.com/moving.
7:23 pm
here's what the president said tonight about prosecuting steve bannon for contempt of congress. >> i did not, have not, and will not pick up the phone and call the attorney general and tell him what he should or should not do in terms of who he should
7:24 pm
prosecute. [ applause ] >> but i answered the question honestly and i think that anyone who does not respond to that kind of question from the legitimate committee in the house of representatives of the united states senate should be held accountable. >> today the house of representatives voted 229-202 to refer steve bannon for criminal prosecution. nine republicans voted with all of the democrats to hold steve bannon in contempt of congress. congresswoman liz cheney, congressman adam kinzinger, fred upton, john katko. nancy mace, brian fitzpatrick, congressman anthony gonzalez and congresswoman butler. congresswoman cheney and the vice chair of the house select committee investigating the
7:25 pm
january 6th attack said this about her republican colleagues who will not vote to refer steve bannon for criminal contempt. >> there are people in this chamber right now who were evacuated with me and with the rest of us on that day during that attack. people who now seem to have forgotten the danger of the moment, the assault on the constitution, the assault on our congress. mr. bannon's own public statements make clear he knew what was going to happen before it did, and thus, he must have been aware of and may well have been involved in the planning of everything that played out on that day. the american people deserve to know what he knew and what he did. i reserve the balance of my time. >> this afternoon house speaker nancy pelosi transmitted the criminal contempt of congress referral of steve bannon to the u.s. attorney's office in
7:26 pm
washington, d.c., where it was received at 5:30 p.m. today at a house judiciary committee hearing, attorney general merrick garland said this. >> the house of representatives votes for referral of the contempt charge. the department of justice will do what it always does in such circumstances. it will apply the facts and the law and make a decision consistent with the principles of prosecution. >> joining our discussion now is congresswoman madeleine dean of pennsylvania, she is a member of the house judiciary committee and served as a house impeachment manager in the second impeachment of donald trump. thank you very much for joining us tonight. i want to begin with where we just ended, and that is the attorney general's comment today. it's difficult to imagine him saying anything else under these circumstances, and yet, there is more suspense tonight in washington about what this attorney general will decide than there has been in a long
7:27 pm
time. >> and yet, lawrence, thank you, number one, for having me tonight. it's a pleasure to be with you. i was in that hearing room today with attorney general merrick garland, and if you flash back, sadly, to the last administration and how difficult it was to have then attorney general barr come before us, it was refreshing that we had merrick garland there and that he so thoughtfully said they will follow the evidence and the law and where it guides us. a very refreshing, it shouldn't need to be refreshing but a very refreshing moment today. i was proud of that moment. >> is there any response from the justice department that you could accept that was something other than the prosecution of steve bannon? >> oh, i'm -- number one, i'm so pleased with our committee and moving so swiftly, and making
7:28 pm
sure that we brought the vote to the floor of the house tonight and made sure that the referral was made to the department of justice. so yes, we saw in the last administration -- under the last administration a dragging of feet, a department of justice that was wetted to the trump administration in a very perverse way. we are still going to learn more about. so today was a really good day, i have to tell you that, a strange intersection of literally attorney general merrick garland speaking before the judiciary committee of which i am vice chair and a member and then literally going to the floor of the house to hold bannon in contempt of congress. and i want to remind people that mr. bannon is a small player in this. he's a big player in the corruption, but much more importantly will be that the
7:29 pm
facts come before the american people, come before congress. we uphold our oversight responsibilities and let everybody know exactly what happened so that we never let it happen again. this was an attack on our democracy, an attack incited by a failed former president, an attack of americans by americans. i know you know this, lawrence, but an attack by americans on americans where there was destruction, there was violence. there was literally desecration, and there was ultimately death and an attack on our democracy. we must never let it happen again, and we know we're at threat that it could happen again. >> today's vote on the house floor was about january 6th. i imagine that would have brought back some feelings about what it was like to be on that floor on january 6th when the people, steve bannon was clearing for were attacking that
7:30 pm
building and trying to get into that chamber. >> strange you should say that. there was a very sweet moment tonight where the spouses of members of congress had a chance to be together in a social way, and i was standing next to dean phillips, he's my classmate and my friend and colleague, and he and i recalled being on -- in the gallery standing next to each other as i called out shame and he called out other things in terms of what was going on on the floor of the house. you know what happened? sadly the republican party knows no shame, and that's what really worries me the most. this is a party that has become a cult. it's a party that has lost its soul and its way. i really commend liz cheney and adam kinzinger. i hope they reclaim this party for themselves and for our country. we need a healthy two-party system. but i stood there with dean
7:31 pm
phillips tonight and recalled our moments up in the gallery where we called out shame and where he called out that it was just outrageous, the false arguments that members, elected members of the republican party were making in terms of trying to defeat our election. sadly january 6th is not the end of what has happened. what we are at risk for now is a repeat of january 6th and, sadly, something much worse. >> congresswoman madeleine dean, thank you very much for joining us on this important night. we really appreciate it. >> thanks for having me. >> thank you. and coming up, the trump cult is trying to turn fantasy into history. that's next. into history that's next.
7:32 pm
this is... ♪ ♪ this is iowa. we just haven't been properly introduced. say hello to the place where rolling hills meets low bills.
7:33 pm
where our fields, inside and out, are always growing. and where the fun is just getting started. this is iowa. so, when are you coming to see us? ♪ ♪ (burke) i've seen this movie before. (woman) you have? (burke) sure, this is the part where all is lost and the hero searches for hope. then, a mysterious figure reminds her that she has the farmers home policy perk, guaranteed replacement cost. and that her home will be rebuilt, regardless of her limits or if the cost of materials has gone up. (woman) that's really something. (burke) get a whole lot of something with farmers policy perks. wait, i didn't ruin the ending, did i? (woman) yeah, y-you did. ♪ we are farmers. bum-pa-dum, bum-bum-bum-bum ♪ ♪ i like it, i love it, i want some more of it♪ ♪i try so hard, i can't rise above it♪ ♪don't know what it is 'bout that little gal's lovin'♪ ♪but i like it, i love it♪ applebee's. now that's eatin' good in the neighborhood.
7:34 pm
what do we want for dinner? applebee's. burger... i want a sugar cookie... wait... i want a bucket of chicken... i want... ♪♪ it's the easiest because it's the cheesiest. for people living with h-i-v, keep being you. kraft. for the win win. and ask your doctor about biktarvy. biktarvy is a complete, one-pill, once-a-day treatment used for h-i-v in certain adults. it's not a cure, but with one small pill,
7:35 pm
biktarvy fights h-i-v to help you get to and stay undetectable. that's when the amount of virus is so low it cannot be measured by a lab test. research shows people who take h-i-v treatment every day and get to and stay undetectable can no longer transmit h-i-v through sex. serious side effects can occur, including kidney problems and kidney failure. rare, life-threatening side effects include a buildup of lactic acid and liver problems. do not take biktarvy if you take dofetilide or rifampin. tell your doctor about all the medicines and supplements you take, if you are pregnant or breastfeeding, or if you have kidney or liver problems, including hepatitis. if you have hepatitis b, do not stop taking biktarvy without talking to your doctor. common side effects were diarrhea, nausea, and headache. if you're living with hiv, keep loving who you are. and ask your doctor if biktarvy is right for you. today donald trump said the insurrection took place on november 3rd.
7:36 pm
no, mr. trump, i'm sorry. that's what we call an election. we know an insurrection when we see one in this body because we lived through one. >> donald trump issued a written statement today saying, quote, the insurrection took place on november 3rd, election day, january 6th was the protest. donald trump was trying to turn his fairy tales about the election into history in the minds of his supporters. this is not the first time mythology has been used to shape what we think of as american history. the new documentary "civil war" which will premier on msnbc this sunday is about the story america tells itself about our history. it shows that the history of the civil war that i was taught this in high school was a mix of history and mythology. >> we never really had a racial
7:37 pm
reckoning. the problems started first immediately after the war. if you want north and south to get together and get along again, you don't talk about causes and consequences. you talk about the mutual valor on that battlefield. >> joining us now is david blight, professor of american history and african-american studies at yale university. he's the author of "race and reunion: the civil war in american memory" and eugene robinson, he is an msnbc political analyst, and professor blight, let me begin with you, and there is that perennial question of what does the civil war mean to us now, which you can ask at any time on any day in our history, but it seems much more vivid now. >> it does seem more vivid now, and it has seemed that way especially since the massacre in
7:38 pm
charleston in 2015, if not even before. a whole host of events and reactions have brought the civil war back into our consciousness. but it's always also there in every way we discuss reconstruction, whether it's about the meaning of the 14th amendment, the meaning of federalism, the meaning of federal power versus state power and of course the meaning of race and the meaning of equality. as long as we have a politics of race, we will always have this politics of civil war memory. the two go hand in glove for better and for worse, and that statement by trump, you know, it's just one of a million now of these orwellian statements that says two is false and night is day, but it's really no different than the kinds of arguments that the lost cause
7:39 pm
mythology developed in the late 19th century saying they never fought for slavery, saying they were only defeated by superior numbers and resources, saying that they never lost on the battlefield and saying that their racial system of slavery was really this benign institution now crushed by the northern laviathon. those stories, those myths took years and years to develop and take over the culture. it still remains to be seen whether what trump and trumpism is doing constitutes a new lost cause, but they're getting very close to it. >> let's listen to more from the msnbc documentary "the civil war". let's listen to this. >> no one on the civilian side, on the confederate presidency was ever forced to concede and repudiate what they believed, and we allowed a group of people
7:40 pm
that waged an orlando insurrection against their government to build statues to their heroes. so that has kept it alive. we have never solved the core problem of the civil war. >> eugene robinson, will they be somewhere building a statue to insurrectionists from january 6th? >> you know, i really fear that someday they might. i mean, lawrence, as you know, i grew up in a time and a place where the civil war was still very present a century later, and in my hometown of south carolina on the main street there's a confederate memorial that was erected in -- not right after the civil war but in 1892 when as profession blight has said and has written so el kwat
7:41 pm
-- eloquently when this myth of the lost cause was being constructed, and it took a long time to build, to elaborate and to embed in the american consciousness. things have speeded up now, so who knows whether this mythology of january 6th, this mythology of november 3rd will actually take root in that way, and i also must say that i am a huge fan of professor blight and anyone who has not read his medesterial biography of frederick douglass should do so. >> i want to read a passage of the -- >> thank you. >> -- fbi excerpt, their interview with one of the attackers of the capitol, the one who actually was tasing officer fenon, this is a very violent attacker in the capitol.
7:42 pm
and he said to the fbi, we thought we were going to thit hit it like a civil war. there was going to be a big battle. i thought that there was going to be fighting for some reason in different cities, and i thought that the main fight, the main battle was going to be in d.c. because trump called everyone there, and we thought we were being -- we were part of a bigger thing. we thought we were being used as part of a plan to save the country, to save america, save the constitution, and the election, the integrity. professor blight, they thought that they were the leading edge of a civil war. >> well, that poor man. it's a shame he can't think for himself about any of this, but yes, they apparently did see themselves as part of a larger movement, a larger phenomenon. ever since that day i have wondered and been thankful that they didn't have more guns. i mean, thank god they didn't,
7:43 pm
and if they'd have stormed into the capitol shooting, we don't even want to think how many people would have died and been casualties, but this is this mentality now of grievance, of resistance, of rage against whatever they're choosing to rage against, against big government, against pluralism, against abortion in some states, against immigration, against our contiing pluralistic american society that trump tapped into. there's no question about this, we've been saying this for years, a layered rage in american society and called out on january 6th. but every time i think about january 6th now or i get asked about it, to me i go back to other points in history where we had similar coup d'etats. this is not a new thing. it's the first time it's ever
7:44 pm
happened in the u.s. capitol, that's for sure, but the wilmington massacre and coup of 1898 in north carolina and many others like it, that happens to be one of the most egregious, and one of the most violent, that too was a situation where the white supremacist leaders of that movement said they would protest killing 60 people to take over the north carolina government. the real insurrection they said had been reconstruction and the ways in which black people managed to create a fledgling kind of new equality and actually get elected to office. we've been here before, but this is a very serious moment about just what as you asked eugene, what will this event become for this american right wing? will it become their new martyred moment around which they develop a lost cause, or will just enough of them come to their senses and give it up?
7:45 pm
>> professor david blight, thank you for joining us tonight. thank you for participating in the msnbc documentary. eugene robinson, as always, thank you very much for joining us. and author isabel wilkerson will join us next. the best things america makes are the things america makes out here. the history she writes in her clear blue skies. the legends she births on hometown fields. and the future she promises. when we made grand wagoneer, proudly assembled in america,
7:46 pm
we knew no object would ever rank with the best things in this country. but we believed we could make something worthy of their spirit. i'm not getting through the pandemic just to end up with the flu. i asked for fluzone high-dose quadrivalent. it's the #1-used flu vaccine for people 65 and older. fluzone high-dose quadrivalent is the only vaccine approved by the fda for superior flu protection in adults 65+. i'm not letting my guard down. fluzone high-dose quadrivalent isn't for people who've had a severe allergic reaction to any flu vaccine or vaccine component, including eggs or egg products. tell your health care professional if you've ever experienced severe muscle weakness after receiving a flu shot. people with weakened immune systems, including those receiving therapies that suppress the immune system, may experience lower immune responses. vaccination may not protect everyone. side effects include pain, redness, and/or swelling where you got the shot, muscle ache, headache, and general discomfort.
7:47 pm
other side effects may occur. all flu shots are not the same. i raised my game with fluzone high-dose quadrivalent. ask your doctor or pharmacist for fluzone high-dose quadrivalent. ♪ darling, i, i can't get enough of your love babe♪ ♪girl, i don't know, i don't know,♪ ♪i don't know why i can't get♪ applebee's. now that's eatin' good in the neighborhood. i always protect my voice.
7:48 pm
it's how i make my living. and you and i make a country with our voices. your vote is your voice. but more than ever, our freedom to vote is under attack. so please: call congress. tell them to pass the freedom to vote act. to protect our ability to have our say on the issues that matter most. so, let's pass the freedom to vote act and protect all our voices. ♪ limu emu & doug ♪ and protect got a couple of bogeys on your six, limu. they need customized car insurance from liberty mutual so they only pay for what they need. what do you say we see what this bird can do? woooooooooooooo... we are not getting you a helicopter. looks like we're walking, kid. only pay for what you need. ♪ liberty. liberty. liberty. liberty. ♪ you could be working with someone outside your company
7:49 pm
and wait for back and forth e-mail, or a call to be rescheduled for the third time. orrr... you could use slack. and work faster with everyone you work with, together in one place. slack. where the future works. our next guest is pulitzer prize winning journalist isabel wilkerson, "the warmth of other suns". and last year she published another master work "caste: the origins of our discontents." in caste, isabel wilkerson writes this about the aftermath of the civil war. it turns out that after the war, many white northerners felt a greater kinship with the former confederates who had betrayed the union than with the people whose free labor built the country's wealth and over whose
7:50 pm
freedom the civil war had been fought, and the north's conciliatory embrace of the former confederates compelled frederick douglass to remind americans that there was a right side and a wrong side in the late war, which no
7:51 pm
and how the majority of americans don't get a chance to not gotten the opportunity to know our country through history, our true and full history. one of the reasons why i can say that because of the books i have written, one of the major responses i get is from people they say to me, i had no idea this happened in our country. i had no idea. and not having an idea is consequences. when people don't have an idea is hard to see what we have in common and hard to get on the same page of how we go to where we are. it's hard to understand how we happen to be where we are. when you think of the civil war. most wars, it's the victors who write the story. it's the victors who direct the monuments. in our country, it was those
7:52 pm
defeated and ended up erecting monuments to themselves. and some memorializing the symbolism and dominating the narrative from a nation to gone with the wind. there is never a true reckoning after the civil war and for that reason, we are still reliving it. it's almost as if there is a feedback that continues to this day. >> it seems and i am just throwing this out there as one of the things that didn't happen that could have left the marker of a reckoning, if for example there had been some penalties exacting on the state that made war on the other states, if we said okay, welcome back to the united states of america, each one of you now get one senator instead of two. and we would have that permanent
7:53 pm
thing about a price, there is something happened for which a price had to be paid. >> you are right. there were no consequences. there were no consequences to moving forward. when i think about how disconnected we are from our history speaking to your point, you know it's hard to get past the idea of slavery and the fact that slavery was a central part of the american of the southern economy and the southern way of life. it's one of the central aspects of what the war was about. i want to say a little bit about what slavery really means how it's connected to where we are now and first of all, slavery lasted for so long and 246
7:54 pm
years. that's 12 generations. to begin to imagine and comprehend how long slavery lasted. it lasted so long, this is an important thing to know. it will not be until next year, 2022 that the united states will have been a free and independent nation for as long as slavery last. slavery lasted for so long that no adults alive today will be arrive at the point african-americans would have been free and for as long as african-americans were enslaved. that'll happen for 2111. it will not happen for the 22nd century that african-americans will have been free for as long as they were enslaved. there will be parody between freedom and enslavement. that's an astonishing silvering way of looking at, what our
7:55 pm
country has been through. we have not addressed not much, those of us alive today have to find a way to explain to succeeding generations, how is it that we saw a confederate flag inside the united states capitol this year, january 6th. how is a rioter able to deliver the confederate flag further than robert e. lee. this is a reminder that we are still living with the after math and consequences of this war. >> isabella wilkerson, thank you very much, as always for joining us tonight, i really appreciate it. >> tonight's last word is next. it >> tonight's last word is next
7:56 pm
at vanguard, you're more than just an investor, you're an owner with access to financial advice, tools and a personalized plan that helps you build a future for those you love. vanguard. become an owner. regina approaches the all-electric cadillac lyriq. it's a sunny day. nah, a stormy day. classical music plays. um uh, brass band, new orleans. ♪ ♪ she drives hands free... along the coast. make it palm springs. ♪ cadillac is going electric. if you want to be bold, you have to go off-script. experience the all-electric cadillac lyriq.
7:57 pm
this is wealth. if you want to be bold, you have to go off-script. ♪ ♪ this is worth. that takes wealth. but this is worth. and that - that's actually worth more than you think. don't open that. wealth is important, and we can help you build it. but it's what you do with it, that makes life worth living. principal. for all it's worth. trelegy for copd. ♪ birds flyin' high you know how i feel ♪ ♪ breeze drifting on by you know how i feel ♪ [man: coughing] ♪ it's a new dawn, it's a new day... ♪ no matter how you got copd it's time to make a stand. ♪ ...and i'm feelin' good ♪ start a new day with trelegy. no once-daily copd medicine has the power to treat copd in as many ways as trelegy. with three medicines in one inhaler, trelegy helps people breathe easier
7:58 pm
and improves lung function. it also helps prevent future flare-ups. trelegy won't replace a rescue inhaler for sudden breathing problems. tell your doctor if you have a heart condition or high blood pressure before taking it. do not take trelegy more than prescribed. trelegy may increase your risk of thrush, pneumonia, and osteoporosis. call your doctor if worsened breathing, chest pain, mouth or tongue swelling, problems urinating, vision changes, or eye pain occur. it's time to start a new day. ask your doctor about once-daily trelegy. and save at trelegy.com.
7:59 pm
it's another day. ask your doctor about once-daily trelegy. and anything could happen. it could be the day you welcome 1,200 guests and all their devices. or it could be the day there's a cyberthreat. only comcast business' secure network solutions give you the power of sd-wan and advanced security integrated on our activecore platform so you can control your network from anywhere, anytime. it's network management redefined. every day in business is a big day. we'll keep you ready for what's next. comcast business powering possibilities.
8:00 pm
on a programming note on this discussion tonight, you can watch the peacock's reverse "civil war," you will want to watch it more than once, it's an important documentary. that's tonight's last word, "the 11th hour" with brian william starts right now. good evening, once again day 275, the biden administration, the fate of donald trump's key ally, steve bannon, house of representatives referred him to doj for possible criminal contempt charges, the one time head of trump's campaign, later chief strategist refused to cooperate with a

32 Views

info Stream Only

Uploaded by TV Archive on