tv The Lead With Jake Tapper CNN October 1, 2021 1:00pm-2:00pm PDT
can president biden bring his agenda back from the brink? "the lead" starts right now. the president just arrived at the capitol hoping to convince democrats to save his agenda instead of killing it. does the longtime dealmaker still have it in him? and -- could be revolutionary. merck says it's a pill that can cut the risk of hospitalization or death from covid in half. plus, it's money meant to fight the effects of the deadly pandemic. why is the state with one of the worst covid rates in the country trying to spend your money on
prisons? welcome to "the lead." i'm jake tapper. breaking news in our politics lead. moments ago president joe biden arriving on capitol hill and now meeting with house democrats hoping to mend the interparty skirmish. one member of democratic leadership, hakeem jeffries of new york, expressed optimism this afternoon that the delayed infrastructure vote will happen today. and he says it will pass. >> the speaker has indicated we're going to vote today. i expect a vote today. i expect that the bill will pass today. >> whether or not that happens depends on if progressives in the house democratic caucus are happy with the progress made on a separate piece of legislation, the much larger build back better act. a bill that would expand social safety net programs such as medicare or child care. we know a compromise has been floated by the white house and
by democratic leaders. a topline number of $2.1 trillion but there is no indication yet if moderate democrats, such as joe manchin of west virginia, who said he wanted $1.5 trillion, as a top line number, whether he is willing to go that high. and if progressives who have already compromised down to $3.5 trillion are willing to give any more. let's get straight to capitol hill and ryan nobles just outside the meeting room. ryan, a lot is riding on this meeting. >> yeah, no doubt about that, jake. and the president of the united states came here to the basement of the u.s. capitol to this room behind me about ten minutes ago. we heard loud cheers and applause from his fellow democrats as the president attempts to broker some sort of a deal between the progressive and moderate wings of his party with the goal of advancing his massive domestic agenda. the negotiations over two massive spending bills stalled on capitol hill, took a turn today with a key player taking
an active role in the talks. president joe biden. after lawmakers failed to meet thursday's self-imposed deadline to vote and pass biden's $1.2 trillion infrastructure plan, house and senate leaders have been furiously in search of a path forward that both progressive and moderate democrats can agree upon. >> we're just going to keep working as hard as we can. we'll see how far we get. i don't believe in arbitrary deadlines. progressives contend they won't vote yes until the senate passes the much broader $3.5 trillion social safety net package first. a process that would take weeks to become a reality. >> we need a vote. we need to be real. are we going to deliver universal pre-k to this country or not? are we going to expand health care to our seniors and include vision and dental or not? >> reporter: still the white house is hoping enough progressives would soften their stance if they were given an
agreement on a plan that all the key players, like moderate senators kyrsten sinema and joe manchin as well as progressive lion bernie sanders signed off on. they offered a compromise of $1.2 trillion to both sides but no one appears ready to bend. frustrated moderates are growing annoyed that progressives won't yield. there is more than just a biden agenda on the line. funding for surface transportation projects across the country has run out meaning thousands of workers are furloughed until funding is extended. >> 4,000 lives and families that may be furloughed because of us. come on. yes, we'll have to, but i hope we don't get to that point. i hope we can pass this. >> reporter: lawmakers have a backup plan to push through a more targeted funding bill tonight if talks around the much bigger package falls apart. amidst all this chaos, the house speaker nancy pelosi who has navigated choppy legislative waters like this before. and continues to promise her troops everything will be all
right. >> so the house speaker maintains that they remain on this path but where that path is heading we still aren't quite sure. it's important to keep in mind this deadline tonight is self-imposed. these negotiations could continue for some time and that may be part of what comes out of this meet with the president. it's also important to keep in mind that some of the key players involved in these negotiations aren't even here in washington. kyrsten sinema of arizona is back in her home state. her staff saying she had a medical procedure to take care of but that she's in touch with the white house. without all the key players even in town it's hard to imagine that a big breakthrough is in the offing but that's exactly what president biden is in search of in this room behind me. >> cnn's ryan nobles on capitol hill right outside the room where it happens. let's discuss. i'm trying to imagine what's going on there. biden's heart is with the
moderates. he wants the infrastructure bill to come up and is looking at the progressives who want a deal on the build back better act. it's not going to be enough, i don't think, for him to say i give you my word as a biden, this bill will happen. i don't think that's going to be enough for talib and jayapal and pressley and the other progressives. >> biden is the guest of honor at this particular dinner party but the person hosting the party is nancy pelosi. and nancy pelosi may not be so much in tune with the moderates as she is with the progressives. i mean, what i'm being told by people who have worked for her in the past is this is where her heart is and this is the moment where nancy pelosi kicks into high gear. she loves this part of the negotiating process. this is what she lives for. don't count her out and her heart might be more with the progressives than the moderates. >> i don't think she loves having to put off a bill vote two times in a week. >> negotiation, though, let's do it. >> the timing of this session because you don't send the
president up to the hill to be embarrassed. you have to wonder what they know that we don't know in their vote counting. >> yeoh ou think that -- >> extra credit. >> oh, look what he did. this is an existential moment for this administration, for this agenda. >> for the democratic party, all wrapped into one. so you don't send a president up to talk to a caucus to embarrass himself. unless they are taking a huge risk that i can't imagine. so they must be close to something. >> something. jackie, congresswoman jayapal told reporters this morning she wished ed biden had gotten invd sooner. >> it's hard to say. you've heard several house democrats say that particularly because we're at a point in the numbers game that every house democrat counts and that is -- when it comes to rank and file, that's not normal. usually there's some padding, some wiggle room. that's not the case right now.
but i just don't know that that would have helped in this particular situation. but he has been talking to jayapal. she told our reporter sam brodie that after she was on rachel maddow drawing a line, biden called her and said you're doing a great job. can't wait to talk to you some more. that's biden charm offensive for sure but he hasn't been totally absent, but i think for some members, he could have done more. >> m.k., i can't recall a time that the progressive caucus flexed their muscles this much. they basically got the house infrastructure -- the bipartisan infrastructure bill was supposed to be on its way to the president's desk in a way. >> last night could not have been nancy pelosi's favorite t time. she was supposed to have it in her bag. and the reason it's not in the bag and i appreciate the likes of sinema and manchin acknowledging this is because the numbers are truly bonkers. even the low-scale version would
be $3 trillion-ish if you did the 1.5 plus the 1.5-ish. and there are $2 trillion between the progressives' progress and manchin and sinema's position. they did the hard part. they got it through the senate with 67 votes. they're part of this. the squad over here is nah, nah. and they say to hell with your bipartisan infrastructure which i'm kind of surprised they've hung on this long but $2 trillion is a large gap to close. >> it's the only leverage they have. they only have leverage if that bill is not passed yet. >> but i also predicted earlier they weren't going to say no to something with that sweet, sweet trillion behind it. >> a week ago we did not have a number. this was an artificial deadline nancy pelosi put in place and now she has a number on the table. they're now in the middle of figuring out what this thing is. it could be possible the momentum of the last couple of days is what will take them into
the final deal. >> not entirely an artificial deadline because you just heard congressman dean phillips there of minnesota say that -- he called it bif which stands for bipartisan infrastructure. if infrastructure doesn't pass, 4200 employees of the department of transportation who don't get the funding to come in are going to have to be furloughed. so if that were to happen and then all of a sudden you have local news teams and cnn and others profiling these people who don't have paychecks coming in because the democrats can't get their act together and pass legislation that is assured passage in the senate. that's not going to be good. >> and they know how foolish that would look and could pass a little stop-gap and fix that for a moment. i don't think it has escaped anyone that this looks completely irrational that they'd vote against a bill that they like that the public has a 70% approval for, which is the
infrastructure bill. and that they wouldn't take less on the larger package because they never had anything that big before. >> yeah. >> and it was interesting to hear bernie sanders the other day rail against this. but he's never had anything this big before either. and he's the chairman of the committee and i'm wondering whether -- how many ways there are to skin the cat on that difference that you talk about. >> one of the problems is rhetorically, progressives have made the $1.5 trillion if that's all that passes it, a losing prospect for them. >> the build back better act. >> a loser today. we'll see where they are next year running tv ads. >> i was told it was 3700, not 4200 department of transportation employees. last night moderate democrats in new jersey, josh gottheimer who has been one of the ones pushing we need a vote on infrastructure as soon as possible. he said he was 100% -- i'm sorry, 1,000% sure there would be a vote last night. obviously, that did not happen.
and progressive congresswoman ilhan omar tweeted in congress we don't make predictions like this until we know we have the votes. some of us get this. others bluff and fall on their face. hopefully@josh gottheimer and the other 4% of democrats will not obstruct and get this done for the people. that is a flex. the progressives are like, we know what's going on here and you don't, moderates. >> and 1,000% is washington math. more than exists in 100. rhetorically, progressives have not backed off at all today or yesterday really and then sinema leaves town which seems to send a message this faction over here, part of it, is not backing down either. i do not know how that comes together tonight. >> but the 4% kind of being -- dismissing them like that, you're not in the majority without that 4%. and there's a reason they are pushing back on some of these numbers because they don't think
they can run on go back home and run on this. there's disagreement whether if they don't pass build back better, whether the highway funding will be enough to run on. that's a 2022 conversation. >> sorry. one other piece here which is the congressional black caucus is looking at this. they aren't thinking about joe manchin. they're thinking about raphael warnock. he needs this bill to run on in georgia. i saw a poll yesterday that 70-something percent of african-american voters would prefer the bbb bill, the build back better bill, over the infrastructure bill. so there is a dissonance between what's happening in west virginia with the coal miners and in georgia with black citizens inside atlanta. >> i want to touch on something jackie said because it's significant. nancy pelosi used to refer to them as the majoritymakers which were the moderate democrats from swing districts that made her the house speaker. jason alt meyer from pennsylvania. joe manchin does not get
replaced by a more liberal democrat, right? >> no. >> who knows about arizona. i find it hard to imagine that the same happens with sinema, but especially with joe manchin. if joe manchin were not there, then the democrats would not be in control of the senate. none of this debate would be happening. >> that's right. but they still hate him. >> raphael warnock, too. if he's not there in two years they don't get the majority. >> there's a fundamental question over whether the $3.5 trillion is existential which way? as you're pointing nout georgia, it may work out well for you. in west virginia and other places, not so much. >> which is why the erosion of trust is problematic. >> it's pretty grim. thanks, one and all. appreciate it. have a wonderful weekend. coming up -- one massive state is planning to require all eligible students, all, to get the covid vaccine to come to the classroom. plus one governor now trying to use badly needed covid relief
funds for, well, another purpose. we'll explain, next. ndicate recording has started.] [car honking and street noise] [inaudible shouting and clashing] ♪ ♪ [horse neighs] [phone clacks as it closes] ♪ ♪ we're carvana, the company who invented car vending machines and buying a car 100% online. now we've created a brand-new way for you to sell your car. whether it's a year old or a few years old. we wanna buy your car. so go to carvana and enter your license plate answer a few questions. and our techno wizardry calculates your car's value and gives you a real offer in seconds. when you're ready, we'll come to you, pay you on the spot and pick up your car, that's it. so ditch the old way of selling your car, and say hello to the new way at carvana.
topping our health lead, governor gavin newsom announced the most populous state will become the first to require a covid vaccine for eligible k through 12 students if they want to attend school in person. this as the drug company merck announces a new anti-viral medicine to treat covid. jason carroll reports for us now. the merck treatment is not actually the best way to battle the virus. >> reporter: it could be a game changer in the battle against covid-19. the pharmaceutical company merck says it has developed a pill that interim results from one trial show cuts the risk of hospitalization and death in half if you get infected. if authorized by the fda it would become the first anti-viral pill to treat
covid-19. >> if you start having symptoms and are identified as having covid, then you could take the pill and it will reduce your risk of hospitalization and potentially death. but it's reduce. this is nothing nearly as powerful as getting a vaccine. >> reporter: merck says it will seek emergency use authorization as soon as possible. the development was welcome news at today's white house covid-19 briefing where medical experts cautioned the pill would not be a stand-in for getting vaccinated. >> if approved, the right way to think about this is, this is a potential additional tool in our toolbox to protect people from the worst outcomes of covid. i think it's really important to remember that vaccination as we've talked about today remains far and away our best tool against covid-19. >> reporter: the battle over vaccine mandates is about to shift to california. it's just become the first state in the country that will require
all eligible public and private school students to be vaccinated to attend in-person. >> i want to get this behind us. get this economy moving. make sure our kids never have to worry about getting a call saying they can't go to school the next day because one of the kids or a staff member tested positive. >> reporter: the new rule will be phased in by grades. once the fda grants full approval for kids 12 and older. on the other side of the country, another deadline looms over vaccine mandates for teachers in new york city. the public schools' employees have until 5:00 today to have at least one shot or risk being forced on unpaid leave come monday. this after a group of employees filed an emergency petition with the u.s. supreme court asking it to put a stop to the mayor's vaccine mandate. new york's mayor says 90% of the city's department of education employees have gotten at least one dose. this teacher says she is ready to be fired rather than get vaccinated. >> i'm going to be terminated.
it's going to be my last thing. >> reporter: but the chancellor says they have enough substitute teachers to cover for the unvaccinated. jake, the fda also announced its advisory committee is going to be meeting to discuss booster data that is surrounding the moderna and the j&j vaccine. those meetings are expected to take place october 14th and october 15th. to date the fda has only approved booster shots with the pfizer vaccine and that's only for certain adults. >> jason carroll in new york, thank you. appreciate it. joining us now, dr. sanjay gupta. author of the new book that comes out next week, "world war c -- lessons from the covid-19 pandemic and how to prepare for the next one." can't wait to talk to you about that book next week. can you explain in layman's terms how exactly this new possible pill from merck, how it
fights covid. >> sure. let me preface by saying that bacteria and viruses are different. viruses need to replicate within a human cell whereas bacteria don't which is why antibiotics are easier to develop for bacteria than antivirals. we don't hear much about antivirals. as the virus is replicating, it's using different building blocks to make new viruses. what this drug does essentially acts like one of those building blocks like a trojan horse or wolf in sheep's clothing, jake. and then the virus starts to build with this abnormal building block and it messes up the replication process. so the virus can't replicate that much anymore. that's basically what it does. two things to keep in mind. you'd understand why you need to give this drug early. you want to stop replication early. if it replicates a lot, then the virus is already out there quite a bit in the body. this virus, this covid virus is tricky. it has a proofreading mechanism
which is like a very sophisticated thing and can usually figure out when something is awry. this particular drug seems to bypass that proofreading mechanism as well, which is what seems to make it so effective. >> if the fda were to authorize this new drug from merck, it could change outcomes for a lot of people. but the white house today, they are begging people, don't rely on this. you still need to get the vaccine. take a listen. >> it can prevent you from getting covid in the first place. and we want to prevent infections, not just wait to treat them once they happen. >> the white house seems to be concerned that the news of this pill to treat covid might dissuade people from getting the vaccine to prevent it in the first place. >> yeah, i think that that's a legitimate concern and we see that with flu as well. even prepandemic, only about half the country would get a flu shot every year. tamiflu is not nearly as effective as what we're talking
about here. people would often rely on that sort of thing. i want to show you what the trial has shown so far, according to the company. we've only heard from the company so far so the fda has to give this a very thorough review. but basically when you do all the math here and realize the people who got the pill, the five days of pills, two days -- two pills a day, that it was basically 7% of people who received the medication were hospitalized versus about 14% who didn't receive the medication that either were hospitalized or died. so 50% is -- that's where they get the 50% number. but in terms of the overall efficacy, the vast majority of people who get covid still aren't going to the hospital. this trial is about 14% of people who went to the hospital or died. this cut that in half. so it's significant, but without a doubt, it's so much better to, obviously, prevent the disease from happening in the first place. and as you and i have talked
about from very early days. it's not just about life and death. there's a lot about this virus we still don't understand including the long-hauling symptoms. it's still perplexing some of what we're learning about this. >> one detail jumped out at me from the merck press release. the company consulted with the fda, as well as with the independent committee that looks at the data and merck has decided they'll stop recruiting new patients into its study, quote, due to these positive results, unquote. did they stop their study early? how unusual is that? >> it's unusual, but it's not unheard of. you typically have studies stopped because it's pretty clear the thing is not working. it's just futile to keep going with the study where it's clear there's no real positive outcomes. so this is a real show of faith that these independent board comes in and say, look, this looks so good. we shouldn't continue with the study anymore. we should put this through the fda process. it's still got to go through quite a bit of processing, including a rigorous safety sort
of evaluation. those are going to be some important questions that come up. but it was a very positive sign, jake. >> currently only one antiviral drug that proved to treat covid as of right now in the united states. remdesivir. how is this new one from merck different? >> i think one of the biggest things is remdesivir is an i.v. whereas this is oral. taking two pills a day for five days you can do this at home. do this in many places around the world. when it comes to some of the medications like remdesivir and monoclonal antibodies, they aren't available in many places around the world because they require you to get the infusion. so i think access is one of the biggest differences here. if you look at the data on remdesivir as well, it's not -- didn't look as promising as what we're seeing here. remdesivir, it wasn't clear it prevented death. may have prevented severe illness and likely hospitalization but didn't prevent people from dying. >> dr. gupta's new book is
"world war c -- lessons from the pandemic and how to prepare for the next one." it comes out next tuesday. dr. sanjay gupta, thank you. clean up. the vice president's office trying to contain the outrage over a smear of israel that the vice president did not correct. now de tractors say it's clear she might not be ready for the number one job. stay with us. what happens when we welcome change? we can transform our workforce overnight out of convenience, or necessity. we can explore uncharted waters, and not only make new discoveries, but get there faster, with better outcomes. with app, cloud and anywhere workspace solutions, vmware helps companies navigate change-- meeting them where they are, and getting them where they want to be.
faster. vmware. welcome change. ♪ ♪ i know the best coffee spot in town. i can make a rustic cabin feel modern. i am a guidebook for guests. i can make an indoorsy person, outdoorsy. i give families a home, not just a place to stay. i am a vrbo host. ♪ ♪ ♪ (music) ♪ staying on top of your game takes a plan. that's why at aetna, we take a total connected approach to your health and wellness. with medicare advantage plans designed to surround you
with the care you need every day. aetna medicare advantage plans (vo) at t-mobile for business, unconventional thinking means we see things differently, so you can focus on what matters most. whether it's ensuring food arrives as fresh as when it departs. being first on the scene, when every second counts. or teaching biology without a lab. we are the leader in 5g. #1 in customer satisfaction. and a partner who includes 5g in every plan, so you get it all. without trade-offs. unconventional thinking. it's better for business.
breaking news now. the white house is confirming that president biden's meeting with democratic lawmakers just ended. he arrived right before 4:00 p.m. to try to smooth tensions between the two sides of the party. moderates and progressives and figure out how to bridge the chasm about the total cost of his agenda and what should pass and when. we'll bring more information about that to you when we have it. in our politics lead, until then, frantic damage control by vice president kamala harris' office that points to possibly deeper and more troubling problems for the democratic party. on one level, harris upset supporters of israel by failing to correct a student who falsely accused the country of genocide in a question to the vice president. groups such as the anti-defamation league argued that allowing smears of this kind to stand can incite violence against jewish people all over the world. the other and perhaps larger issue for the democratic party
as sunlen serfaty reports is what this incident might say about harris' political acumen given the expectations she will, once again, run for president. >> reporter: vice president kamala harris is in damage control mode after this exchange with a university student earlier this week. >> -- funds allocated to continue backing israel which hurts my heart because it's an ethnic genocide and i think that the people have spoken very often in what they do need and i feel like there's a lack of listening, and i just feel like i need to bring this up because it affects my life and people i really hair about. >> reporter: harris responding in part -- >> this is about the fact that your voice, your perspective, your experience, your truth cannot be suppressed. and it must be heard. the point that you are making about policies that relate to
middle east policy, foreign policy, we still have healthy debates in our country about what is the right path, and nobody's voice should be suppressed on that. >> reporter: israeli publications jumped on harris for not pushing back against the characterization against palestinians as ethnic genocide. and sources tell cnn calls came into the white house from several leading jewish organizations expressing their concern. the vice president's office is now scrambling to minimize the fallout, putting out a statement today saying the vice president strongly disagrees with the student's characterization of israel, that it was the student who voiced a personal opinion during a political science class. emphasizing the vice president has been unwavering in her commitment to israel. harris' senior staff is working the phones calling several leading pro-israel organizations to make clear that harris' silence did not equate agreement with the student's claim of ethnic genocide. >> there's nothing wrong with
criticizing policies of the state of israel. but it's deeply problematic when you demonize or delegitimize the country because we've seen how that kind of slander is used and can spark anti-semitic incidents here at home. >> reporter: this dust-up is just one in a series for the vice president in her nine months on the job. in june her first foreign trip overshadowed by her blunt delivery of this message to guatemalan migrants. >> i want to be clear to folks in this region who are thinking about making that dangerous trek to the united states/mexico border, do not come. do not come. >> reporter: that answer upsetting many, including members of her own party, in calling into question her diplomatic chops. just days later harris causing headlines again by dismissing the criticism that she has never been to the border. >> we've been to the border. >> you haven't been to the border. >> and i haven't been to europe.
i mean, i don't understand the point that you're making. >> reporter: there have also been reports about dysfunction and infighting in harris' office. she's recently brought on two more communications aides to help manage all of this. and back on this most recent dust up, many of the groups we spoke to today who were concerned about her response to that student, they say they are satisfied by the white house's outreach today. >> sunlen, thank you. breaking news for you now. the meeting between president biden and house democrats on capitol hill has ended. and moments ago, we heard directly from president biden. take a listen. >> whoa, whoa, whoa. thousands of different questions and they're all legit. i'm telling you, we're going to get this done. >> when? when? >> it doesn't matter when. doesn't matter whether it's in
six minutes, six days or six weeks. we're going to get it done. >> why has it been so challenge -- >> very interesting. ryan nobles is live on capitol hill right outside the meeting room. and ryan, you heard the president there saying, it's going to happen. we're going to get it done. doesn't matter if it's in 6 minutes, 6 days or 6 weeks. we'll get it done. what are you learning about what president biden said inside that closed door meeting? >> yeah, jake, i think what the president said about the timing of all of this happening is so important and it's echoed by what we're hearing from lawmakers that are exiting the room. the president making it clear to the -- these democratic members of congress that he wants to see both pieces of legislation passed. the bipartisan infrastructure bill and that much bigger social safety net package and he wants to see them passed at the same time. so that means it's not going to happen today. the house speaker has not officially pulled this
legislation from the floor or officially said there isn't going to be a vote today but from what the lawmakers are telling us as they exit this room, the president made it clear that he does not need that bipartisan bill passed this week as what was originally the plan after moderates pushed for that a couple of weeks ago. part of why that was frantic is because of the self-imposed deadline. originally monday and then pushed to thursday. now here we are into friday with no vote being taken and that's mainly because the votes weren't there to make it happen. progressives were insistent that they wanted more of a guarantee about that much broader reconciliation piece before they voted on the bipartisan bill. it seems as though the president came here with a clear understanding of the reality of this situation knowing that he didn't have progressives willing to take that vote without the
reconciliation piece but also from what the lawmakers are telling us as they exit, his own personal desire. it seems very clear that president biden will not be satisfied with just the infrastructure package. he wants that much broader social safety net. he made that clear to them in the room here today. jake? >> interesting. ryan nobles. let's talk about this. one thing we can say is that this is a victory for the progressive caucus which was saying -- has been saying you can't pass infrastructure without passing the larger social safety net bill. nancy pelosi, the speaker of the house, one of the most powerful speakers we've ever seen in this country, said, i'm going to put infrastructure on the floor of the house on monday. that was a commitment made to moderates. that did not happen. she said i'm going to put it on on the floor thursday. there are not the votes for that. so without question, i don't know who wins in this other than the progressives showing they really have power here. >> which is different. we haven't seen this before where they've actually held
their ground. now the question is, what number is their floor because they said when it comes to the build back better bill, how -- they -- manchin has made it clear he doesn't want to go over $1.5 trillion. they've said that's too low. so now we're in negotiating phase. what's it going to take? that's what we're going to be trying to sus out over the next six weeks, six days. >> we still don't know where kyrsten sinema, the other holdout in the u.s. senate on this. manchin has said -- he said 1.5 is where i'd like to be. we still don't know what sinema thinks about all of this other than we hear that she really objects to the corporate tax increases in this bill. >> she's talked a lot about taxes. she's not in washington right now. and, you know, i think what we heard from the president there was his understanding that this is a governing moment for him
and for the democrats and, if you don't get something done, we're all in a heap of trouble. you know, it seems to me there was a little bit of -- i would say consternation saying it doesn't matter when we do this. enough of this phony deadline. we just have to get it done, and we're going to get it done, and i think the message is pretty clear. you guys -- we have to figure this out because fail surnot an option. >> jamal, one of the things to explain to people. if it's not ready y didn't they bring it to the floor? they brought it to the floor to force people to vote for it. urgency in washington, d.c., makes people make a decision. makes people make a move. so it's not really quite true with all due respect to president biden, whether it happens in six hours, six days or six weeks. it doesn't matter. it does matter. six weeks, maybe nothing will happen. >> it does matter. here's the reason it matters. i think it matters because we
all remember the obamacare experience where both sides kept arguing. it looked like a mess. even though they did a really big important thing that changed people's lives, people didn't feel that way about it for a long time. it had a lot of stink on it. you don't want this process end up the same way where people feel like even though they're getting a lot of good things out of it, it has a lot of stink on it. think about this from the progressive side. they're not getting policing reform. we don't have any movement really on voting rights. they got to get something out of the deal. i think that's probably digging their heels in here and not letting go. >> there is no deadline now which means this will stretch to god knows when. $2 trillion of work to do in between, and there is going to be a stink on it, as there should because we should talk about what is in $3 trillion worth of stuff. >> that's what joe biden will be doing next week. he's going to be going out on the trail, which some criticized barack obama for not doing, and trying to sell what is in this package to the american public.
so i don't know if he's going to be talking about $2 trillion or $3 trillion but he's taking it on the road which you might argue he should have done before, but i think they realized that they have a sales job to do with the american public. >> yeah. >> to m.k.'s point, do you not think if the focus, let's say, by president biden and vice president harris and others, is not, let's talk about free day care. let's talk about senior care. let's talk about expanding medicare. let's talk about all the climate change provisions, et cetera, that that will be more positive for their message than this whole $3.5 million versus $1.5 million? >> i think it was a mistake to say $1.5 million is the sell. big doesn't mean good to everybody. you have to explain what is good. a lot of people think big means bad and you'll rile up those people. >> thanks one and all again. coming up -- more of the breaking news from capitol hill. first, what is the state of
alabama using your money for instead of spending it to help fight the effects of the pandemic? we'll tell you next. stay with us. but it's also a game, of information. because the nfl is connected. and at any moment, the fate of the season can come down to this. billions of secure connections, per second. when the game is on the line and the game is always on the line touchdown! the nfl relies on cisco.
breaking news now. moments ago, alabama governor kay ivey signed legislation into law that would allow the state to use federal covid relief funds to build new prisons. this is money that the federal government sent to states to help them plug budget shortfalls caused by the pandemic, but in alabama, one of the hardest hits states with almost 15,000 reported coronavirus deaths, as
cnn's dianne gallagher reports, the governor's idea is being met with a bit of criticism. >> reporter: the state of alabama planning to use millions in covid relief funds to build new prisons. >> we've got an alabama problem and we're going to get an alabama solution. >> reporter: that solution, a roughly $1.3 billion package laid out in a series of bills to build two new prisons while closing or renovating the existing ones. the majority is paid for in bonds and through the state general fund but up to $400 million, more than 30% of the total cost would come from the money issued to alabama under the american rescue plan. it's a move republicans say is legal under the broad federal guidelines. >> not only to prohebitions are now cannot spend these funds on a tax cut or -- and you can't use the funds to prop up your pension program. >> reporter: just because it may be legal doesn't mean it's the
right thing to do. >> we haven't done our due diligence in terms of responding to the covid crisis. it is in my view, morally reprehensible for us to even consider using those funds. >> reporter: alabama is among the states that get more federal funding than they provide in federal taxes. the state currently has the fourth highest covid death rate in the nation and is in the top ten when it comes to the covid case rate per 100,000 people. >> our nursing homes need this money. our rural hospitals, especially, need this money and because our rural hospitals are failing our urban hospitals need this money. >> we had meetings just yesterday regarding people who still need rent assistance on a massive level. >> those funds were earmarked for things like that. >> reporter: the governor's urgency to address the prison problem stemming in part from a lawsuit filed by the trump department of justice last year that alleged conditions and the violence in alabama's prisons violate the u.s. constitution. this week new york congressman
jerry nadler asked the u.s. treasury department to block alabama from using federal covid funds to build prisons. writing, quote, the american rescue plan is an historic effort to provide urgent assistance in a time of great suffering. it should not be used to worsen our national problem of overincarceration. governor ivey shot back accusing nadler of overstepping and insisted the funds can be used for, quote, lost revenue. >> nothing about this is going to be easy. >> reporter: now that this is law in the state of alabama, the question remains on whether the federal government will step in to prevent them from using those covid relief funds. republicans have been asked if they have a backup plan just in case. they've responded, jake, that they don't think they're going to need one. >> all right. dianne gallagher in montgomery, alabama, thanks so much. president biden just met with democrats on capitol hill. has he managed to bridge the chasm between moderates and progressives? we'll talk to one of those
democrats next. stay with us. ♪ ♪ (battle sounds stop) ♪ ♪ (dragon roar from phone) ♪ ♪ (dialing sound) (inspirational music) - hey, kaleb, what's up? how you doing? - hey. i'm good. guess, what? i just had my 13th surgery. - really? i just had my 17th surgery. - well, you beat me. - well, i am a little bit older than you. - yeah, it's true. (alec chuckles) how are you doing? - i'm doing good. i'm encouraged by seeing how people are coming together to help each other during times like these. - kinda like how shriners hospitals for children is there for us. imagine if i couldn't get my surgery, who knows what would have happened?
- same for me. i know my shriners hospitals family will continue to take care of kids like us who need them most, all because of caring people like you. - like me? (alec laughs) - no, the people watching us right now at home. - oh! those people! hi, people! - kaleb and i know not everyone can help right now, but for those of you who can, we hope you'll call the special number on your screen right now. - [kaleb] you'll be making sure our amazing doctors and nurses can keep helping kids like us who need them now and in the days to come. - your gift will make a huge difference for kids like us. - oh, oh! show them the thank you gift. - okay, okay. hold on a second. with your gift of $19 a month, we'll send you this adorable love to the rescue blanket as a thank you and a reminder of the kids you're helping with your monthly support. - so, what are you waiting for? you can use your phone and call, or go to loveshriners.org to give
and join with thousands of other generous people who change lives with their gifts every day. - i think that's about it, buddy. good job. - my pleasure, capt'n. [kaleb] please call now. if operators are busy with all the other caring people,. please wait patiently, or you can go to loveshriners.org to give right away. - [alec] big or small, your gift helps us all - [alec and kaleb] thank you! (happy laughter)
working at recology is more than a job for jesus. it's a family tradition. jesus took over his dad's roue when he retired after 47 year. now he's showing a new generation what recology is all about. as an employee-owned company, recology provides good-paying local jobs for san franciscans. we're proud to have built the city's recycling system from the ground up, helping to make san francisco the greenest big city in america. let's keep making a differene together.
human rights violations. but leading this hour, our breaking news. president biden just moments ago wrapped up his meeting with house democrats on capitol hill with nearly his entire agenda at stake and saying this to the cameras on his way back to the white house. >> whoa, whoa, whoa. you asked me a thousand different questions. they're all legit. i'm telling you, we're going to get this done. >> when? when? >> it doesn't matter when. it doesn't matter whether it's in six minutes, six days or six weeks. we're going to get it done. >> in a few minutes i'll talk to a member of the congressional progressive caucus to find out if president biden was able to move the needle at all inside that room behind closed doors. first, let's bring in jeremy diamond at the white house and cnn's lauren fox on capitol hill. lauren, you are hearing that president biden actually laid out a range for a top-line
number for the big build back better bill to expand social safety net spending? >> well, that's right. coming out of this meeting we're talking to members and trying to understand exactly what happened in that room. representative quellar told us that the president laid out the fact that $3.5 trillion for the social safety net plan is what a lot of democrats would prefer. but he did say that this may have to be somewhere in the range of $2 trillion, which is a much smaller number, of course, than that $3.5 trillion. and that's always because of those two members over in the senate, kyrsten sinema and joe manchin, moderates who made it clear they're not comfortable going as high as $3.5 trillion. so obviously that was a very significant moment to some members who were listening closely. and cuellar told us he viewed it as the president trying to make clear to progressives, i'm on your side. i'm fighting with you but we have limitations given the diversity of perspective in our
caucus. that was one of the messages. another member i spoke to, representative quigley told me this was an olive branch conversation. this was not the president demanding anything from anyone. this was the president reminding everyone that they are on the same team after a week in which the moderates and the progressives have been deeply divided, deeply entrenched in their positions and no one has been willing to budge. so the president coming toorksd sp today, speaking for a half hour. he offered to take questions but i'm told members in the room deflected. got up and gave him a big applause and some members encouraged him not to take questions in a joking manner because of how long things could go. this was the president trying to bring folks together. i'm told the move was positive. that people were feeling optimistic. but he definitely tried to lay out a few parameters around what members should be expecting, jake. >> lauren fox. jeremy at the white house, what do you know about the white house calculations for