tv [untitled] July 9, 2021 5:30pm-6:01pm +03
has been crowned rather winner of the us national spelling bee for the 1st time in the competition. his history, n u r r a y. that is the 14 year old villa avenue guides from louisiana, one the event after correct, the spelling mariah a subcategory of plant. i'm gosh, who is also an accomplish basketball player? whole 3, get his world record full fall. we tried to use scripts company. i'm proud to name you that i her again, i'm fully back with the headlines on al jazeera, the taliban claims it controls 85 percent self territory. and i've got to stand a taliban delegation is in moscow. and in 5th, it's open to a sci fi with the afghan government. russia said it's received assurances that there'll be no cross border aggression, didn't every machine, but if we see a steep escalation of pensions and they have gone project border,
the taliban has quickly taken many board districts. and now has control of about 2 thirds of the border with tajikistan. a russian military basin tajikistan is equipped with everything necessary to help the republic in control in the border situation. if needed, additional measures will be undertaken in the spirit of the russian public alliance . to prevent aggression or territorial provocation, factory fire has killed more than 50 people in bangladesh had feared many more still trapped inside the building outside the capitol. darker doesn't suffered injuries, trying to escape from upper floors police in haiti go for foreign less. mary's was behind the fascination of president juvenile marie of detained to haitian americans in more than 20 colombians columbia government. so some may have been former members of the military. the french president has reassured leaders of africa, whole nations that france is committed to the struggle against armed groups. and many of my call who said the leaders of the g 5 countries after announcing france
would withdraw 5000 soldiers destroyed to the region. south africa as high court has dismissed an application by former president jacob might just spend it's vacant . sentence serving a 15 month term for failing to attend a collection inquiry. south sedans, president has promised peace during a ceremony making, marking a decades since independence suffered on became the world's youngest country when its fits from sudan in 2011, but suffered a civil war which killed about 400000 people. and a un investigator says illegal israeli settlements good amount to war crimes. special laboratory michael make spoke to the human rights council. was hundreds of palestinians protested against settlements and occupied westbank. the village of bates. l is really forces cause the number of injuries. those are the headlines on ologist era during obligate. i will have a news our for you after the stream stay with this. clear out. one of the
world's most famous film festivals is back with love mandatory and doors, the social distance thing in place in some countries unable to attend. and like 2 or 3 pieces, recreate the magic high temperatures the council festival. now who's for the okay, you're watching the stream today. we are looking at hong kong, one year of the national security law being in place. the log is the police and security 40 sweeping powers to arrest citizens. we go 1st to hose and child, he's the vice chairman of 38. that is a probe by using coffee in hong kong. and he here is addressing some concern. well, i think as long as you own the bader law, you don't coco against national security. i see nothing that they need to feel very
let me take an example. apple daily is not only a haploid, but it's also a prop, again, the done against central government. so if you are running a media with an agenda to sort of thing during our countries national security, there's something wrong, isn't it? well, is there something wrong? what do you think you are part of this conversation? you can be in the youtube comment to be part of our discussion. what we are asking our guest all is hong kong. now a police state. let's meet our panel. we have katrina, we have been we have ins like it to have all of you on board on the screen. katrina, remind our audience. you are what you do. hi everybody. i'm the china correspondent for al jazeera reporting out of aging. but traveling nationwide here in china get to happy, katrina. hello saying welcome to the stream. you told him who you are. so hi
everyone. my name is phil long, so i'm one of the circle, hong kong wanted hong kong national law. i was also one of the 10000 arrestees of the hong kong pro democracy movement. going to have you and i welcome back to the string reminder audience you are and what you do. i'm american national, sharing independent commentator. i'm on over $24.00 channels in china and internationally for any given month by month, 12 channels been year 24. so i guess i'm going to start with how much do you think hong kong has changed in the last 12 months with the national security law being now in place? this is what we offer our online community. and here is one response. i would love to see thin and katrina and i know if you agree, let's take a look. since the implementation of the national security law is chilling facts of
c, t p goes everyday life. so for instance, many put mark would be patient to spend the time and then politicians being present i've gone into exile further in educational spaces, textbooks, and public library books to the democracy and sensor to pull off the shelf and journalist other than facing more and more rec haven persecution most recently and, and popular for democracy newspaper apple day, we were foster closed. so given all of these repression right now and political organizing and reading events become incredibly risky. so a big challenge that home home or space is to find the trinity spaces in ways to continue building our connections. a relationship to one another. does that description of hong kong in the past year? does that resonate with the thing?
yes. so i took to work with her, and i would say it is much more than the shooting fact in hong kong. so in hong kong, because of the home and gauge are not going to call in the nation with the law. this is the have, has lost the freedom of speech or this angry press freedom. i think freedom and other civil liberties because of our office, if you are correct, i'm off. i put a the we have last last pro democracy newspaper, hong kong. so you may think what needs that we have witnessed, there is no real flaw. so we have lost the potential of private property rights. we've also lost the freedom of the press. so i don't think hong kong could be qualified as an international financial center anymore. well, i would really highly doubt that it's that, i mean the number of i p o that are going through hong kong are very high level right now in terms of the overall, i mean, hong kong is now peaceful. you're not having the kind of chaos that you has for 4
years since 2014. i mean there's a lot of people who are affected by that. there been interviews with them. they were running small businesses. they're at a very dependent on the tourism trade and things like this. so they really kind of, you know, it depends on what you're perspective. it's now fin says pro democracy, well, for some pro democracy is pro independence. and there's this line between them and basing in their mind was extremely, you know, they restrained for those 4 years, while in essence there was a lot of chaos going on the streets. the 1st duty of a government is to make sure the people are safe and their property a safe pro democracy movement. some of them were peaceful, but there was a large contention who decided to take matters into their own hands, beating people they were really harming people. you, everyone saw what happened. well, the number general and you and i was like,
i respect, but i know saying about the business community and i do agree that it's about perspective. but i think also that there's more to democracy, that democracy is also about democratic values. and from a reporting perspective, i've been living in china for about 8 years now, and especially it's about the, the beginning of that time, most traveling between beijing and hong kong. and i always noticed that there was a stark, very stark contrast. hong kong was a place of vibrant discussion where people were allowed to just said were protest. it was a part of the culture that journalist went there to, to cover protests. and the government, the, the police force helped to facilitate that. and descent was normal. you didn't have to be brave to be able to, to be critical of the government here and aging. it's different. i mean, in, in the mainland china, in mainland china. it's stock. there are no protests allowed to said is only for
the very brave or for people who are seen as not having much to lose. and i think the way i see it is bay ging or mainland china is a play. some people lower their voices, they whisper when they're being critical. katrina, you're, you're a very western view of this whole thing. i mean, this, the truth is that most asian societies and you're from singapore, there is a high re, like are you that is paste? i'm sorry. oh, i'm sorry. yeah, sure, sure. but i mean, i mean let me just, singapore, these other places. let me just give you a visual and then you can pass what you see, what i'm saying. so this is july. the 1st celebration here on my laptop that the handing over of hong kong from the british back to china. and the difference in the crowds in 2003, 2019 and 2021 thing. what's your explanation for this?
so this is a direct direct result of the nation with the law. so for the last 20 years we have to transition off. i think 1st off, july or march in victoria park and hong kong island that because of the nation is akila. we don't have such a freedom in hong kong. we don't even have the right to have peaceful or kendall likes the josie hall called for the 10 i'm we're massacre. so i don't think measures of kilo is a to that could promote the international status of the, of the city instead of just destroying the city. so the number of the, all the amounts of people to send records and what does that mean, that hong kong is qualified for being and it has international financial center. these are 2 different things. i'm just going to tell him, but since shed and originally that it, it's somehow you've lost property rights and that there's is inference. it's. ready a hong kong was disappearing. i mean, i understand his perspective, but you know,
i would put a question to you. where did you get all of these ideas? i mean, while the british were in hong kong, after seizing it by force, so they could sell drugs to china. where was democracy then? i mean, it seems to be too many in beijing that it was a kind of delivered a town poison pill by the depart high. and i want to ask you a question that you post and go ahead. yeah. so i, so if you look at the history, especially those and classify the files from the for one coming office from the doctor much, you can see that for the lot 50 to 70 years, do you take off them? i have been trying to introduce them according reform, comprehensive democracy reform to hong kong, but because of the mandatory french or pressure from beijing. the hong kong up british debris to hong kong government couldn't figure the history of grants of
and military things until in the very beginning i'm just going to bring some of our audience as views as well to put them to you. alex strong says katrina, you take this one. he's never been to hong kong before. it's not even a shadow of its own self. now quick response, katrina, go ahead. i think when you look at the ability to speak out people the ability of people to express what they, they say is important or criticize the government, if you that's what made hong kong special is a part of chinese territory. there's very few opportunities to do that. elsewhere in china, so from that perspective, hong has completely transformed. they've seen people punished activist protesters, journalists, politicians, and people themselves are afraid, they're afraid to speak out. they're afraid to have an opinion which is different from the official narrative. and if they're not directly in told or threatened or
intimidated into silence, they are self censoring because of it and cannot on you choose your says that they can do whatever it wants. i know. go ahead. ok, so katrina, you're based here in beijing. we have this conversation on a fairly regular basis. we talk about the long term situation. what is the duty of a government is provide primary. the 1st thing is to provide a safe place. if you're not safe in your home, if you're not shaping your business and your schools, what's the point of all these theoretical things? the idea that a ballot box and a open market is the only way that you can run a country is belied by the with the progress that china, mainland china has had. over the last 40 years. you look at other places where you have, quote, democracy, look at haiti, i mean it's a poster child for what has failed both in terms of i'm going to bring us back to hong kong if i may, i know because hate the news agenda right now. let me just show you, hey,
on my laptop screen this, this is you for a very long time. when you are protesting, you stayed under the rated radar. you stayed secret because you were afraid for your safety. what made you then reveal your identity? why did you come out? so i have b g. i have accidentally become a 1st since june 2019. and for more than one and a half year, i have the under the reader. but in august 2020, my identity was exposed by some prohibition newspaper in hong kong. and they reported that the ccp has issue royce to arrest me under the so called national 60 law, for example, cruising reform forces. so i would like to tell i know that even to kinda interfere with from media like this one could because cedar colluding with foreign forces. so, and that's why today there are no hong kong pro democracy to face or x of lawmakers
willing ordering to take this interview or this program. so i would like to show this chilling effect and a problem of the hawk on national security law to you to you are no longer in hong kong. i know, let me play this to you. this is an activist and a policy advisor who is talking about the pro democracy at the 5th. now having to go underground, have a listen. have a look at the election system is so rick, that we are almost certain most of the face must a super majority of the state will be fielded by pro china politicians. so there is no meaningful way within the system to fight for freedom and democracy. the situation hong kong is very bye. but as always i have faith in the people will go when the pop within the system the know
back, i think what they would do and what i encourage them to do is to pursue a path outside the system. well, i mean it's, it's very fine for him to sit outside and recommend that other people go to jail for so verse of activities and things like this. but you know, this, the everything is being framed here in the sense that there's freedom and democracy being called for hong kong is part of china that's there's nowhere that, that is disputed. we're pushing the freedom of expression somehow completed with this idea that, oh yes. and that means that it's a fight for independence. i think that's really one thing that i just great because what you're seeing is it is it is a slow and steady kind of change of the way the system is working in hong kong. and
i think i liners points are valid and that we are seeing in hong kong what some have described as this mainland design is ation. basically, that hong kong is very slowly going in that directing in that direction. the system is coming closer to what we see happening across mainland china and that is sadly for the people in hong kong who value the democratic values at hong kong, once represented within chinese territory. this opportunity speak out to criticize the government. that is not something that there is much space for in the chinese system because of the way it works. we have a one party system here that there is no opportunity to overthrow that party. so there is a one specific narrative that aging needs to maintain in china is very, very little room for little else, for the sake of stability, the waging season. and that, that, that is also being reflected in the way that the central government is pulling hong
kong now and making an overhaul to the, to the way the political system works there. yeah. my way of doing that. yes. go ahead. yeah, thank you. yeah. so i also need to remind, i know that there has to be there is no british joint declaration under which the purse freedom democracy to another file should be preserved on the such international treaty. and there should be no change for 15 years. however, we have witnessed the author, 997, had over ordered all kinds of people liberties and freedom accord. correct. well that's not true. after the 97 hand over, those were kept intact until you had 4 years of chaos mean you have to look at it from beijing point of view as well. you know, you're a very idealistic, you're very young. these ideas you came from somewhere. i assume that your teachers said that these were the values that were in cal cation by the british,
when in fact they weren't, the british were not interested in providing democracy until they were about to leave, and they knew that their lease would not be renewed. so, you know, you can revise history just because it's suit your purposes. what we have here is, is simply the struggle between in, in beijing point of view, those who seek to change. and you can china, i was going to build up that point that you may because christopher is what do you right now? and christopher court right says that hong kong is part of china. nothing will change that. it means a new culture and a new way of living that what we are used to in the west that doesn't make china wrong. it's literally a culture clash. thing. i would agree. and that's, that's what it comes down to say i, i know you agree. i'm just interested if, if i'm going to put that to thing, it's like this is the new normal thing. this is china. hong kong belongs to china
and this is what the future is going to look like. thank god. i don't think this is the way the hong kong should look like. and under the british context, which is an international treaty, hong kong on congress, enjoy different kinds of 6 people liberties, for at least 15 years. since the 916 hong kong has local piper and a c p, or they deter any kind of democratic reforms to deter any kinds of different timing issue. right. and even before the 19th hundreds of a hand over a whole, congress have no say in the hand over the issue. so. so actually that's why in 2014, there was there lots of skill umbrella movements. we tried to fight for your new social suffrage, which was guaranteed under the basic law which was dropped upon the ccp themselves . it looked when you can repeat these things, but there doesn't make them true. ok, there was no guarantee you're going to serve versus suffrage. it's not independent
. if you're mad at the hand over talk to the british. they were the ones who to go shaded on your behalf. so, you know, there is not a study serious suggested i don't know if i'm going to not serious. wait a 2nd. i want to challenge you in that. how is that? i'm going to challenge you like my religion in the show. there's not a thing. it's not a serious point to make off the british because we're past that now we're way past last katrina. let me do your pass. you're always passed it when it comes to high. yeah. she not make me live on tv. katrina, come on. i think we got to be more interactive than even the 3 was capable. all right, let me, let me show you katrina. this is the pulse of arrests that we can look at from the national security rule. about 120 people have been arrested. some people will not be out on bail. this is a very serious law. when you look at these numbers that graphic,
what does that tell you about the future of hong kong and particularly for activists that are caught up in court cases right now? i do think there is to it's time to point to i just put it in all defense point. there was a clash of direction here. so the democracy activists, we saw the leading the lead years leading up to this. we're hoping for to go in the direction of more, i guess what i would call western democracy more universal suffrage, but in china's eyes, beijing, as they always feel the direction of hong kong, eventually becoming more like any other mainland province, certainly and 50 years. and the way i sort of look at is kind of, they beijing, as this kind of frustrated parent looked at hong kong, which had all these, i suppose, much more democratic opportunities or rights than definitely any other roles and china, chinese territory and said, well, you know, we gave you the opportunity to, to vote. it wasn't perfect, but we gave this opportunity and then you kind of made
a mess of it with this. what they would describe as riots and all this violence. and therefore you prove that we, we couldn't trust you. and so we're going to take off the, take away these rights much faster than they were already going to do. i think china had the attention of turning hong kong into something that was really more unified, but the rest of chinese toe treat beijing has done. the soley with other parts of china, we've seen it happen inside jargon to bet where they had this unification. kind of nationalistic agenda and this was going to happen to hong kong, but what we saw as a result of, of the, the protest movement evolving the way it was. the way it did was that china basically accelerated at this incredibly rapid pace. these changes besides this national security law, which removed all basically the voice of this democracy movement and really dismantled essentially let me just bringing one more voice. this is joey. if i may, i know bringing this was this, this is joy talking about now, what do you do if you were part of the pro democracy movement?
now, what do young people do? have a listen, have a lot through her mentation of the national security legislation in july 2020 some content from international financial center. a city where people are so to level freedom and democracy into an open, they're pissed. and under the complete control of the chinese party, the generations of our parents and our grandparents came to hong kong known that this is a fable and process society under the protection of the carmel is upon. com. but now for our generation, we either have to leave hong kong persecution or how to stay in hong kong, and that's the fear every single day. then what happens to you now? so we to be on us home group or the pro democracy on congress. we are struggling to suffice in hong kong receipt because this is via credit done by asian. and we have
one seen jonathan china already. if we don't stop at all, we all may be the international community. don't stop the ccp from creating more. seen john, it could be the end of the call, but we do think that this is the last chance to fight and we will continue to resist the ccp and document in hong kong should be off the people by the people and for the people it's really interesting, a lot of us constitute there's a lot of conversation on youtube comments section about why don't you just off con condos, what they want? is that even possible right now? katrina? i think what is important to note is that in china we have a one country system we need. i mean, aging needs basically unquestioning loyalty from its population because it doesn't want obedience by force. obviously will use force if it needs to, but it wants people to choose the, the communist party. they want to choose the company's party based on true belief.
and it's lead to, to see that it's doing the right thing for the people now on the mainland. that's easier, especially among the older generation because they've grown up with the communist party and seeing the difference between maybe they grew up in the time or they experience a time of chaos where they couldn't eat. and now things have markedly improved. and so they have more of this loyalty, but in the younger generations. and certainly in hong kong who didn't have this opportunity, they didn't grow up with that and said they grew up in a more of a globalized world or world where they could look across. and see the west where people had both their civil civil rights as well as developments and they having to engender this loyalty. and to do that, you need to control the narrative. you need to control the message not enjoy katrina newspapers and on the streets. you need to control it in education, and definitely i only see that direction of trying to continue and do that trainer in hong kong, control it in. thank you. i wanna thank you for the arm wrestling as well. and i appreciate the, the dynamic debate that we all just had and youtube as well. i'm going to leave you
with potentially what might be the new look for young people in china and the kind of education that they may well, thanks for watching. the next time with frank assessments is an argument for suggesting that the martin and ministrations anything along game. it's very much of a warm embrace of iran nuclear deal because of us domestic politics informed opinions, schools and shelters of been reduced to rubble. how do you think this shapes a generation and the politics then we life has been shaped by vitamin in depth analysis of the days global headlines inside story on our jazeera, challenging the way mainstream media report. the news stories like these should be easy pickings for political reporters out of old power to account how it is in journalism in breaking the destruction of civilian property. this is all evidence
for the farm trials and the re speaking now. we've been getting stories of john taken from the houses in the middle of the night and tortured the listening post covers the way the news is covered on algebra. on march 15, 2019 zealand sense of security which chatted when 51 people was shot dead into christ church. another 40 wounded when a gunman began shooting at a christ church, moth with tech worship and attending the friday service. for those who lost loved ones finding ways to deal with the trauma, it's crucial. she gave me what was mom? i told her mom was with me 4 months later i feel much quiet and i feel much more calm and really focused with my life. let us love one. love doesn't
close to lunch and makes your heart happier. my heart happy. he doesn't bring any loss for a new symbol. let us practice this. ah, this is al jazeera. ah, you're watching the news, our life from headquarters, and del heim daddy now. ok the coming up for the next 60 minutes. the gone to the bottom says it controls 85 percent of the country as it tries to moscow. its military gains don't threaten russia or its central asian allies franchise. it will close its military bases in northern molly by early next year.