tv Inside Story Al Jazeera April 28, 2021 10:30am-11:01am +03
and in central america with migration how these are going to impact in key congressional districts in key states so unfortunately all politics is local including foreign policy in other words in determining his international agenda president biden is still putting the immediate political calculations in america 1st james by al-jazeera at the united nations. this is all just over these of the top stories india has seen his worst day so far from the coronavirus with nearly 3300 more fatalities taking the official told past 200000 but the actual number is thought to be much higher hospitals are running out of beds medical supplies and oxygen elizabeth around him has the latest from new delhi the situation as such in delhi that people family members have to climb from
hospital to hospital to have loved ones and method and now gone from predatory and to come a toy and from burial to burial ground to hold funerals in a country where funerals are held soon as possible not just because of custom but because of the very hot temperatures because of a shortage of more trees we think facilities and ask the situation unfolds we have international aid that's been arriving in the country for the last 2 days a lot of different oxygen supply facts of concentrated banta native brazil senators opened an inquiry into the government's handling of the pandemic which could damage president judd also not was bid to be reelected next year brazil has the world's 2nd highest death toll somalia's president has agreed and not to extend his term and is promising to hold elections there's been growing unrest in the capital people have been fleeing mogadishu and residents fear of more violence. at least 5
people have been killed and dozens have been wounded in chad joining protests against a new military transitional council demonstrators are demanding a return to civilian rule after the military took charge last week following the sudden death of president idriss deby a u.s. military ship has fired warning shots at a rainy and naval vessels in the gulf the u.s. says the 3 boats came within 62 meters of the u.s.s. firebolt on monday monday washington says it's the 2nd time it's happened this month there's been another night of protests in elizabeth city in the u.s. state of north carolina demonstrators are calling for justice after the police killing of a black man an independent autopsy showed under brown jr was shot in the back of the head his family says he was no threat to the police and he was trying to flee. those are the headlines the news continues here on al-jazeera in about half an hour's time to inside story goodbye. letter in america
a region of the wonder and joy of tragedy and violence but it doesn't readily to even relate to the killing fields. i've been covering all of latin america in my career i think is the light and it's my job to spread light on how and why. apartheid in israel human rights watch calls the domination of palestinians a crime against humanity israel rejects this and has ignored similar allegations before so can anything be done to hold israeli leaders accountable this is inside story.
hello and welcome to the program i'm homage to him the term apartheid was 1st used in south africa to describe the systematic separation and oppression of people based on their race it's a crime against humanity human rights watch says that's exactly what's happening in israel it accuses the government of enforcing policies to maintain its dominance over palestinians israel has dismissed similar accusations before and it's calling the latest report a piece of propaganda but palestinian leaders say it's a solid account of atrocities adding it's time for international action we'll bring in our guests in a moment 1st this report by harry fawcett in occupied east jerusalem. anti palestinian racism was on show in jerusalem last week with hundreds of israeli far right activists chanting death to arabs the far right thanks to an electoral alliance sponsored by the prime minister now has a foothold inside parliament but it is new report human rights watch makes a broader accusation that the israeli government itself practices apartheid and
persecution and we started looking at it we saw the reality in which a single government rules of the road the area between the jordan river and the train you see roughly 6800000 jewish israelis and 6 for you know you look at it and across these areas israeli authorities systems. indians in fact at least privileged jewish israelis the report focuses on 4 arenas in israel where it says palestinian israeli citizens are discriminated against particularly in terms of land use in the occupied west bank where palestinians unlike israeli settlers a subject to military law and where settlers have preferential access to land resources and building permits in hamas controlled gaza from which palestinians are barred exit to live in the west bank or east jerusalem and in occupied east jerusalem where unlike israeli citizens palestinians can have their residency
status revoked this is the 2nd high profile report this year that has accused israel of practicing apartheid in january the israeli rights group said the israeli government was an acting jewish supremacist policies in the occupied palestinian territories and inside israel itself israel is again rejecting such charges its foreign ministry saying human rights watch is known to have a long standing anti israeli agenda actively seeking for years to promote boycotts against israel their decision not to share this report for review or comment with any israeli authorities is clear indication that it is a propaganda pamphlet which lacks all credibility but critics point to the 28. the nation state law which defined national self-determination is quote unique to the jewish people and to the fact for several months last year israel's prime minister was advocating the permanent annexation of nearly a 3rd of the occupied west bank how the moms then this is a very important report on israel practicing apos 8 policies the should be the
position of the international community as it was with south africa and they should be punishment against the occupation human rights watch says with no viable peace process in place the situation has gone from temporary occupation to permanent domination it's calling on the international criminal court to investigate its allegations are false it i'll just 0 occupied east jerusalem. all right let's bring in our guests in gaza raji soran a human rights lawyer and director of the palestinian center for human rights in west jerusalem and hertzberg legal advisor to in geo monitor a non-governmental organization that analyzes the output of the international n.g.o.s community from a pro israel perspective and in london william schabas professor of international law at middlesex university welcome to the program let me start with you today palestinian president mahmoud abbas has welcomed the human rights watch report he said in a statement that it's urgent for the international community to intervene do palestinians
feel that this will lead to any kind of change. i want to say. since 20 years since the. world conference against hers in durban south africa. more than 1200 international organizations across the globe said israel is a new brand of apartheid so this is not something you read if you were us as part of the air or international human rights organizations but 3 months ago. say they should which is one of the leading human rights organizations and then tried to report stated in a clear cut way that is right in your brand of apartheid it is apartheid system
no human rights watch which is one of the international meeting ground rights organizations. when we are having in the. state of tight. one of the most legrand. situation and where it's practice and all that is really good practices busy and if your by product the entertainer is and it is very so in a clear cut way this is one brand of apartheid practiced in this part of the world of course we seek tons of. international human rights. organization to have the same position work because everything that we said but most importantly governments as well to respect this fact
to try to change it would. change of keeping this in your brand of apartheid practice. you know when we went to the i.c.c. one of our missions 'd. i'm sorry to interrupt you but i let me get back to you on that point about the i.c.c. in just a couple of moments let me go over to ann right now and in the context of this new report from human rights watch just how explosive is the use of the term apartheid and how seriously does the israeli government take the accusations. well actually i think it's quite interesting that mr serrano you raise the durban conference because in 2001 this campaign did begin in at that u.n. durban conference it revived the hateful canard that was repealed by the un in 1901 as i know as it was racism and a group of organizations including mr serrano nice and human rights watch decided
to revive the civil canard and accuse israel of being an apartheid state and this campaign which again he actually quite clearly knowledge is a political campaign aimed at denigrating the legitimacy of israel itself as a homeland a safe haven for the jewish people has been going on since then and now the charge of apartheid is quite offensive there's been no other context outside of south africa and by calling israel an apartheid state that precisely what is the remedy if they are seeking they're seeking to eliminate that state's so again it's quite clear that the goals are hateful and i would assume that the government would take they know that it's a political campaign and that this is. this is just propaganda. but it's important to take note of the the depths to which many of these organizations that although they claim they're promoting human rights are actually working against human rights william how significant is this new report from human rights watch and from
a legal perspective does the report in your opinion make a solid case that it is an apartheid that is going on. well it's not the 1st allegation the crime against humanity of our being committed by israel or by the israelis as has been pointed out that was done by a major israeli and geo earlier in the year and the allegation has been made in the past as well in a report prepared by richard falk for the united nations some years ago but human rights watch is a very prestigious international non-governmental organization and it doesn't make a charge like this lightly and takes it very seriously i've looked at the report. i find the legal arguments are well set out they apply the international legal definitions this is not a piece of propaganda this is an analysis that's finally rooted in the claim what
apartheid is all about is about a violation of their right that equality and it's about people being treated unequally and the evidence that human rights watch that's what the report says more than $200.00 pages long documents many examples both inside the occupied territories and inside israel proper discriminatory treatment of palestinians and it's the definition of apartheid require that there be an institutionalized regime of systematic oppression it's a crime before the international criminal court so i think the case is settled let's get it before a judge let's let judges decide here few minutes ago you started to mention the international criminal court of course the international criminal court has opened a formal formal investigation into alleged war crimes in the palestinian territories do you believe that this new report is going to factor into the investigation in any meaningful way.
when 'd i think he. opened the gate. they began to do that live in their examination. we submitted one of our submission . policy of human rights busy organizations as lawyers were present victims abs independent professional human rights organisation one of the submissions where precisely on crimes against humanity and persecution and it was intently focused on. apartheid wasn't that big focus on the blockade in gaza strip and so the payment system in the west bank and how palestinians are 'd treated and caught. the editor is by the state of his or her and it was. simply to state very solid
facts we are having. to fight it here is where we are having it will always 'd skim . the places and with noise we get standards for apartheid persecution and the crimes against humanity and a lot of submission. we we do. crimes against humanity and. in this part of the ward so so that's why we are continuing with this line and we are to present it to the plymouth. examination as a human rights organisations one precise sub mission on the cigar and i think one of the things that the i.c.c. going to look at now when they open the investigation so we will
have all the evidence we have all the guys we have all the crimes which broke all of our argument and we have the standards by the way persecution crimes against humanity during one part of the i.c.c. mandate interim step and the fact that this report comes not too long after the decision that there will be an investigation by the i.c.c. is that causing concern among israeli officials and i know that israel has said that it's not going to cooperate with i.c.c. as investigation but is this causing some amount of concern. i mean it's clear that this report and that selling report that was referenced before a part of the program unfortunately funded by many european governments where several of the ngos that they provide money to have decided as part of a coordinated campaign to issue reports making this offensive allegation and i'm
sure the their objective is to try to see if they can influence the international criminal court i think if the prat you know anyone looking at this these reports in an objective way would certainly not consider them to be well sourced or well founded i doubt professor chivas would accept such writings from his students when you actually look at how much of the evidence has been twisted and manipulated a lot of the claims are completely false or to be completely glasses over the rich ethnic diversity within israel and calls on muslims palestinians without recognizing the different communities there are better when strews share casein. so it's from that perspective it's quite offensive also. so i don't think there's a lot of concern it's you know it's just more of the same the same propaganda that . these organizations have been pushing for many years. and when as we have
done with many of these reports in the past when you actually examine the details it claims fall apart quite quickly william in this report human rights watch says that policy makers should going forward shift focus for israeli palestinian peace away from a political solution and more towards a rights based approach is there any chance that we might see that happen. you know it's a very interesting good question because we have this. mixing of the political then new judicial. in in this context and it's always start me as a as a well a fascinating situation the activity of the international criminal court which is purely judicial it's directed at individuals who will be prosecuted for certain crimes the potential that it may have to influence the political developments
there's a very simple political solution to a problem where there is discrimination by israel in the west bank and that's to give the west bank full independence as opposed to the state so one of the solutions that this issue that makes the issue of apartheid evaporates is in effect to create the. i mean to have a proper autonomous independent palestinian state fully exercising the right of self-determination so that's the that's the issue that presents itself i think that israel i mean and was explaining that she says that the facts are poorly set out well if it goes before the international criminal court i don't think israel should be worried about the fact they're going to have whoever will be charged will have a fair trial but i wouldn't be dismissive of the concerns and how this changes the game within israel the charges the prosecutor's been looking at up to date concerns
war crimes and are probably limited to a certain number of precise targets people in the military and perhaps some of them in the political establishment once you make a charge of apartheid it's the whole state that's potentially susceptible to prosecution and so it's very difficult then within israel for people who are in a position of authority in the government to decide whether or not they may be subject to prosecution and i think that ought to be. concern this really does change the the environment in terms of the threat of prosecution to individuals and many of them may reflect upon this and say you know we could we could treat the palestinians a little better we can solve this problem in a civil way by changing the laws that human rights watch has flagged and if they do that then they're immune to prosecution then they've solved the problem that's what they are up to do and i want to talk for a moment about the issue of the cove in 1000 vaccine in israel and in occupied
territories the palestinians say that as an occupying force israel is responsible for assisting them israel says that palestinians are in charge of their health system i bring this up because there are rights groups that have been highly critical of israel in this regard saying that the fact that israel while it has this very successful cover in 1000 vaccine campaign going on the fact that they have not been providing vaccines to palestinian territories that that is a form as they say of medical apartheid what do you say to that. well just on that the factual basis that that charge is false i mean israel has been executed hundreds of thousands of palestinians both within israel and outside you know in gaza and the west bank they've provided you know hundreds of thousands of vaccines they provided medical assistance at the palestinian authority which is in charge of the health care per the oslo accords has actually rejected on many occasions
israeli help and in providing the back scenes from a very early on in the pandemic the house to me is decided they wanted to go along with the world health organisation kodak's program but nevertheless israel has vaccinated all the palestinians that i am enter into israel every day to work on they have a several $100000.00 palestinians and of course palestinians living in jerusalem are entitled they are covered under the israeli healthcare system and so they also have received that scene's to the same degree in which israel has received them so really you know under even under their care and the charges that these these rights groups and or the legal paradigm that they're pushing forward you know israel's in compliance with international law and under the provisions of oslo accords which not only did the palestinian authority mutually agreed to it's been guaranteed by the international community including the un raj what do you say do you believe
that more vaccine should be provided what do you say at these charges from rights groups. pandemic is a. human being and you have to sit confronted to do our best in order ready to overcome it and go there like any other place on the we have the vaccine but why he goes out there to play territory are unique in guns are we have this criminal illegal inhuman siege 2000000 people who the last 14 years go to support kids social committee including other things loved the movement of. sick people 'd who are in very critical conditions are unable to move to it. but it's very systematic way and mean and that's the essence of apartheid
you know suffocated and destroyed the hill system did the machines i mean to come to to gaza in the last 14 years. alone months in a low what a lot of medicine and that's why i mean the ringback health system in the gaza strip almost destroyed and that's what's unique in having a pandemic and when we we have their hands and even the subject teens should be also right by that if you pay from not given it's entirely for legal responsibility according to international law on the state to kick your patient to provide these vaccines that need to the people under there if you're patient but is there i mean doesn't really care about. they
keep us i mean with pandemic i mean quite being with a lot perhaps this is a big shame. for states. like israel i mean to have it if if this vaccine 'd should be authorized anybody the patient not be be given body while we are subject to why we have one of the highest per cent of those who pass or we increase our peers or a loved one and besides those who have this pandemic this is. reality this is. ringback the responsibility of if you're patient and this is a big 'd shame for the state of israel as any pupil country to have to have us with this medical situation now beyond that even cancer cases people don't don't have very 'd you will hear happy for the and people and the only
thing they are having chemotherapy so cancer patients i mean also i mean suffering from now on it people who suffer from the only medical cases can be transferred to receive medical care lifesaving cases which most of them come back to gaza and. come to. be because they go in very naturally to stages i'm sorry i want to say i'm sorry to interrupt you but we're very well roger i'm sorry interrupt you but we are starting to run a time of it and this is a sense of thanks and it looked to me like you might have wanted to jump in there up please go ahead we only have about a minute left so please go ahead. so there is just a crisis and now mr strangways retelling of what's going on in gaza that he completely ignores the infighting between the fact that i heard the initial masts
and the political problems going on in the palestinian authority which is largely responsible for the medical problems happening in gaza so i think that was quite interesting that he admitted that all right we've run out of time for going to leave the conversation there thank you so much to all of our guests and hertzberg who are on the and william schabas and thank you too for watching you can see this and all of our previous programs again any time visiting our website al-jazeera dot com and for further discussion you can go to our facebook page that facebook dot com forward slash a.j. inside story you can also join the conversation on twitter our handle is at a.j. inside story for me mama june the whole team here by for that. one or the put prejudice to it's a wasted list tens of thousands of put out that's how we're in south korea has been
transformed from what still found him to global leader in food recycling i have a reporting on how new technology is making this possible. in kenya i mean the promise and scientists would have been that livelihoods depend on water and a little ice a phrase just. a century ago they were called colonials. 50 years ago and they were immigrants today they are citizens. in the light of france's 2021 contentious so-called separatism laws legal back at the history of muslim immigration in france in it and see. the sins of fronts episode one. on al-jazeera. a tale of 2 presidents. venezuelan military defectors. american must know.
and a bizarre yet old dangerous attempt. at regime change in the bolivarian republic of venezuela. people in power the bay of pigs let's al-jazeera. may on al-jazeera. from a 3rd wave to the vaccine rollout the latest developments as the coronavirus pandemic continues to spread around the world al-jazeera is emmy award winning investigative program is back exploring the fault lines in the u.s. . 16 years since last electing a new leaders alice stimulants go to the polls but will the elections be free from foreign interference from hostile to hostile more hotels explores geopolitical conflicts from the perspective of iconic hotels on the frontlines and former south
african president jacob zuma goes on trial for corruption. may on al-jazeera. india's battle to breathe the desperate wait for oxygen supplies while the confessional covered 900 death toll surges past 200000. i'm about this and this is all to see a live from doha also coming up somalia's president decides not to extend his term after protests and fighting he's now called for early elections. south africa's president to sit around the.